[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

[Advertise on 4chan]

Name
Options
Subject
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]

[Catalog] [Archive]

File: images.jpg (21 KB, 333x499)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
>warfare was better in the middle ages under monarchies because civilians were not targeted, service was voluntary, and warring kingdoms knew when to stop instead of creating meat grinders
Is this bullshit? It sounds like bullshit.
19 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11675336
>The guy thinks property (land) ownership is the natural order of human existence
Source?

>making sure homosexuals are expelled from the community of property owners
Source for this claim also.


> when people say there is no pseudo-libertarian to fascism pipeline
You mean you made two claims, didn't source them and proceeded into conjecture. I'm thinking not an argument.
>>
>>11674561
>civilians were not targeted
being civilian in besieged city thats about to be sacked was fucking horrifying
>>
>>11675429
They're literally in the book in question. They're literally also on the wikipedia pages of both the book and of Hoppe, if you're that lazy.

Pseudo-libertarians and fascists not bring their best, yet again.
>>
>>11674561
Yes, it's all wrong.
>civilians were not targeted
Not only false but many times more than would be today. Unfortunate peasants on site would have their fields trampled, other belongings robbed or damaged. In case they were not wise enough to flee, they could be subjected to all sorts of violence for nearly as many different reasons. Like unruly troops.
>service was voluntary
Misleading. Most of the armies were levied peasants, the full time soldiers were very few in number. Modern fully volunteer standing armies forces existed before WW1 and continue to exist today but had to be complemented by draftees for the actual wars in between. Difference is in the middle ages there were no such downtime periods, at all times there were some peasants away from the fields to go on some campaign until their corvée was done.
>and warring kingdoms knew when to stop instead of creating meat grinders
Plenty of bad examples from back then as well.
>>
File: 20200330111156.jpg (21 KB, 366x493)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
>>11674574
Holy shit, it's like every single word to describe someone as retarded all rolled up into one shit sundae.

File: mein heigth.png (362 KB, 590x614)
362 KB
362 KB PNG
5'9
>>
>>11677468
Either that guy isn't 6'2 or Hitler is standing closer to the camera
>>
>>11677549
4 inches is hardly anything, niggas with 4 inch dicks would know
>>
Chamberlain was a limp wristed anorexic spaghetti man prove me wrong

What went wrong?
>>
Isnt he like the most celebrated Danish king?
Isn't he like their national icon?
>>
>bankrupts the country in endless wars with Sweden and HRE all of which he lost
>>
>>11677633
He reigned for 59 years and in that period Denmark reached it's zenith in terms of European prestige but that has a lot to do with him inheriting one of the most stable and richest kingdoms from his father and he's also chiefly to blame for it's decline. His foreign policy left him with no allies and a shitload of enemies.

What went so wrong?
27 replies and 5 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11671729
They literally have Turks in SnK and Erwin isn't one of them
>>
>>11671717
>>11671833
Safavids were Aryan not Turkic
>>
>>11675328
>mughal empire
Racially aryan?
>>
>>11677115
Nader couldn't even speak Turkish properly, he was fluent in Persian even though I admit he was a Persianized and assimilated Turkmen. He nearly got executed as a kid by the reigning Safavid Shah because he failed at being a messenger.
>>
>>11677115
He was a psycho and then once he was assassinated his realm was divided between his psycho subordinates with the only normal one being Karim Khan Zand

File: comparison.jpg (127 KB, 1542x732)
127 KB
127 KB JPG
Pic: A Sotho politician vs San girl
Obviously there's always admixture among bantu speakers in Africa and I know people with khoisan grandparents/parents. But I've noticed there are people in Southern Africa who look pure khoisan but either don't acknowledge or aren't aware of any khoisan ancestry. Did some people's parents lie to them?
8 replies and 5 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
File: nilotic woman.jpg (85 KB, 333x500)
85 KB
85 KB JPG
>>11677079
>So the first humans were Mongoloid? Or do Khoisan have recent admixture?

Definitely not, "Mongoloid" people wouldn't exist for another 160,000 years by the time the first Khoisan people started popping up. Epicanthic folds have evolved multiple times in humanity, in mostly unrelated (besides being human of course) populations, due to intense sunlight in relatively dry or sunny areas. This Nilotic woman from East Africa has epicanthic folds too, despite likely having no Khoisan DNA at all.
>>
>>11677170
Do you think the people in Botswana have more San than Khoikhoi? I know one who mentioned having that ancestry.
>>
>>11677197
Potentially. They could very well have both for all I know, the biggest difference (physically) between the Khoikhoi and the San is height, with the Khoikhoi being taller, so if Bantus in Botswana with Khoisan DNA are taller than the ones who don't, it might be a sign of Khoikhoi ancestry.
>>
>>11677240
interesting, people from botswana tend to be short. I know you said larping isn't the right word but it still feels like there is too much distance from the khoisan side. E.g. why aren't languages like tswana or xhosa considered hybrid languages instead of just bantu?
>>
>>11677384
It's likely for the same reasons why English isn't considered a Latin language and why Swahili isn't considered a Semitic or Indo-European (Indo-Iranian) language: Plenty of loan words and influences, but the base is still Bantu. Interestingly, the other click languages that the Hadza and Sandawe speak aren't related to the Khoisan languages, outside of using clicks.

File: 177.jpg (21 KB, 500x500)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
Explain what's wrong with National Socialism and why it doesn't work.

hard mode: no moralfagging
307 replies and 44 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11677168
Immensely based
>>
>>11677135
The weak is a pretty broad term. What do you/they mean with weak?
Like if you can't bench 3 plates, you better make your amends?
>>
>>11677168
I love China and I am prepared for the Chinese Century.
>>
>>11672562
Hitler's shitty foreign policy inspired from Wilhelm and Napoleon
Dude literally thinks he can take over Austria, the Rhineland and Poland without repercussion
Same for Italy
A shame cause his domestic policies were good
He should have not invaded Poland and instead try buddying with the Brits and French or form an Eastern Alliance to deter the Soviets
>>
>>11677168
Fucking based

*has flawless presidency*
>>
*does nothing wrong*
*because he did nothing*
>>
>>11677345
A presidents job is not to do good things. A presidents job is to prevent bad things from happening
>>
>>11677337
>absolutely wrecks the economy by fueling an out of control stock bubble
>leaves office just as it pops, taking no responsibly for it
>flawless
Lolbertards are worse than commies and stormfags combined
>>
>>11677446
>people buy shit they don't need on credit
>this is somehow Calvin's fault
>farmers refuse to invest in modernization
>this is somehow Calvin's fault
>>
>>11677541
>A presidents job is not to do good things. A presidents job is to prevent bad things from happening

I’m going to post this every day until you remember it

File: pepe-thinks-space.jpg (82 KB, 640x360)
82 KB
82 KB JPG
Who really decides what is real?
3 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11676959
The Lutheran God
>>
File: Remember the Alamo.jpg (175 KB, 1181x886)
175 KB
175 KB JPG
>>11676977
>>11676985
>Yo, that IS real, but WHO decided Real, yo.
fucking Real is not fucking real you retard.
>>
>>11677019
Jannie Jew decides. The Jews.
>>
>>11676959
me
>>
>>11676959
The Prima Materia.

File: european christianity.jpg (9 KB, 258x196)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
Before Christianity was even a thing, were the ancient Europeans worshipping the same God of Christianity? How does this make sense to Nazis who believe that Christianity is the one true religion for their country yet the ancestors of the Christians were literal pagans. Do they believe they are the ancient Hebrews? Do they think that the Torah was written in Europe?
>>
>>11676827
Since Yahweh is a thunder god and euroshits worshipped thunder gods as one of their main gods then you could say they were.
>>
>>11676841
>Yahweh is a thunder god
I thought he was a universal God. And I'm pretty sure Europeans weren't Greeks.

I thought faunt63 would be the first one to post in this thread, but oh well. I wonder how he would answer, do you think he would post stuff from stormfront or just sh*t he made up?
>>
>>11676827
Actually yes, they were called the God-Fearers.

Some Gentiles progressed to the point of embracing Judaism, accepting circumcision, and becoming proselytes. Others embraced certain aspects of Judaism but held back from conversion. These were often referred to in Greek literature as “God-fearers.” Cornelius is called “a devout man and one fearing God.” The apostle Paul met many God-fearers associated with the Jews throughout Asia Minor and Greece. In Pisidian Antioch, for example, he addressed those assembled in the synagogue as “men, Israelites and you others that fear God.”—Acts 10:2; 13:16, 26; 17:4; 18:4.

Cohen says regarding God-fearers: “Although these gentiles observed any number of Jewish practices and venerated in one form or another the God of the Jews, they did not see themselves as Jews and were not seen by others as Jews.” Klausner describes them as “standing in a middle position,” for they accepted Judaism and “observed a part of its customs, but . . . did not become complete Jews.”

Perhaps some became interested in God because of discussions with Jews engaged in missionary activity or by observing how they were different in conduct, custom, and behavior. Yet, the Septuagint was the main tool assisting these God-fearers to learn about Jehovah God. While there is no way to know the exact number of first-century God-fearers, the Septuagint unquestionably spread some knowledge about God throughout the Roman Empire.
>>
>>11677343
is this the same thing as a Noahide
>>
>>11676827
There's a theory that Yahweh is Jupiter, Roman and Greek pagan religion influenced Judaism and other religions in the same way they did later in return

File: 5e6facfc38196.image.jpg (16 KB, 381x256)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
Is the Pascal Wager the definitive proof that atheists are dumber than religious people?
67 replies and 6 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11677331
>Do you even understand the Pascal Wager?
I do.

>It's literally about not knowing if religion is true, but knowing that if it is then there's no reason to be an atheist.
A premise in Pascal’s wager would be “atheists go to hell” and there’s not even a mechanism by which we could verify that, which is why so many say “but what if god only rewards atheists?”
>>
>>11677341
>Just learn about different religions, read their holy books.
I have for some, not nearly all yet. If you think there is one that has something legitimate to say about the afterlife, I’m all ears, but I don’t see much reason to believe any of those claims as they’ve been presented.

>No religion has a dogma where god secretly loves atheists.
Your language seems to suggest that whether or not a given claim is a tenet of a religion has bearing on whether such a claim is true. If this is what you’re saying, why would that be the case?
>>
>>11675162
Logically there can only be one supreme God
>>
>>11677247
>you have no way to refute it
Of course I can. If you found a god you are a theist and not an atheist, so you're going to hell if you believe that this god exists.
>>
>>11677401
How’s that?

The arguments that mammals deserve moral consideration are compelling. I love my dogs. I know for a fact pigs and cows are sensitive creatures just like dogs.

But I just can't stop eating beef and pork.
28 replies and 1 image omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11677391
Nice non argument dullard. So you gonna actual say why animals are equal to humans? Or keep coping like you have been this entire thread
>>
>>11677382
Anon, I'm not trying to trick you up or anything. This is a discussion. I would hope that we both get something out of it and understand each other. I don't know much about Zoroastrianism. Care to speak on this? As for destroying life, we all do it. I certainly hope to preserve my life as long as I can enjoy it, though.
>>
>>11677091
>arguments that mammals deserve moral consideration are compelling
What arguments exactly?
>>
>>11677091
And the Vietnamese can't stop eating dogs because they're so delicious.
>>
>>11677426
Dog doesn't actually taste that good, predators in general rarely taste nice

File: WaltDisney.jpg (459 KB, 1600x1991)
459 KB
459 KB JPG
One of the greatest men who ever lived.
5 replies omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11675539
>This was a man who battled the international Jew his whole life.
he hired them at his company and went to their weddings.
>>
File: fuck nips.gif (281 KB, 490x639)
281 KB
281 KB GIF
>>11677130
*international* jew. Many jews, particularly american ones were much less obnoxious before the 1967 war.
>>
>>11674983
Unironically, a humble dude who wanted the change the world. It's awful seeing what has become of the company he created
>>
>>11677152
What rot
>>
>>11677246
What’s impressive is that they still hold him in high regard at this point. There have been efforts to defame his reputation across the decades, though.

File: unnamed.jpg (37 KB, 512x298)
37 KB
37 KB JPG
How badly would Shitler have been rekt if he got his war with Czechoslovakia?
6 replies omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11675621
>>11675731
>>11675898
>>11675956
The question is interesting.
In the diaries of Ciano (the Italian foreign minister and Mussolini's son-in-law) he refers to this conversation with Hitler:
>September 30, 1938: In Kufstein, meeting with the Führer. We get into his carriage where, spread out on a table are all the geographical maps of the Sudetenland and western fortifications. He illustrates the situation: he intends to liquidate Czechoslovakia, as he immobilizes 40 divisions and binds his hands to France. When Czechoslovakia is, as he agrees, deflationary, twelve divisions will be enough to immobilize it.
>>
>>11675898
Czechoslovakia defeated Poland and Hungary easily before. Rusyns are not Ukrainians.
>>
>>11675621
Anyone who thinks Czechoslovakia wouldn't have a been a Poland tier stomp is delusional.
>>
>>11677400
Poland was defeated easily because they fucked up the mobilization.
>>
>>11677400
Czechoslovakia had
>better army than Poland
>way more strategical advantage than Poland
>would only fight against big power instead of 2
>would probably get support either by Soviet Union, France or both

File: 1628155617044.jpg (9 KB, 340x226)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
Why did France abandon Catholicism?
34 replies and 4 images omitted. Click here to view.
>>
>>11675640
Revolutionist trannies dismantled Catholicism.
>>
>>11675908
other french anon, it's true and has a lot to do with the fact that the catholic church i still associated with cultural/educational elitism
and except for a few schools until tertiary education the best institutions are all catholic

don't project your insular american reality to the rest of europe because in general europe is more like france in that regard than to the US
>>
>>11676197
It didn't. It really wasn't that big of a deal at all and the accused parties never admitted or had any evidence of being anti-jewish. Jews just keep touting it though because it's become so ingrained in their collective headcanon. Not the first time, but possibly the silliest. Leave it to them to come to a thread about French culture and come in shouting about what a huge victim they are.
>>
>>11676936
While I agree that it's probably overblown since the church-military link wasn't as strong as implied, k think it's probably one of the very few times in 2milennia and more of history that the Jews dindu nuffin and ironically anti semitism back fired on France. Should be noted however that it was the /pol/tards darling Germany that took politically and culturally speaking advantage of this chaos and proclaimed itself far more tolerant to Jews than its neighbour
>>
>>11675640
Hostility towards the clergy for playing a major role in maintaining the ancien regime




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.