What's /asp/'s verdict on The Shield members?
>>12946153Jon is the Dean
>>12946153DEAN'S been exposed the most. No wonder he wasn't given creative freedom or his match ideas listened to.
>>12946153From left to right:Anti dimesNo dimesAll the dimes
>>12946153best matches: rollinsbest promos: moxleybest presentation: reigns
>>12946167>w-we di-di-didn't w-w-want him anyway>>12946168Driving away over 2.5 million viewers isn't "All the dimes" lol>>12946190>best presentation: ReignsWhat the fuck did he mean by this?
>>12946153DEAN is the only one with any balls and also hasn't driven away 2 million viewers
>>12946201>>best presentation: Reigns>What the fuck did he mean by this?they never had Reigns come to the ring pushing a hotdog cart or play second fiddle to his wife
>>12946204You can’t drive away what’s not there
>>12946153Roman was based. The other 2 were indie shitters
>>12946153roman and seth are based. moxley is try hard cringe
>>12946153Mox is the only one worth watching.
They should have been turned into a proper full-blown fujoshit stable and brought in endless teen girl dimes
>>12946153Mox > Reigns > Seth > DEAN
>>12946168WOW you got this absolutely spot on! congrats
>>12946190Recent Rollins cant touch Moxs title reign matches. Hell even Reigns has better matches now, Seth is a complete charisma vacuum flop
>>12946153Seff is a shitterMox is basedDon't know about Roman. Don't really care for him but maybe he's good.
Moxley>Roman>Seth
Mox/Reigns > the distance between earth and the nearest dyson sphere > Seff
>>12946230Instead he punched a pad on the stage
>>12948291Better than kneeing the air, Deanetty
>>12946230They had him get smeared in dog food
Moxley is definitely the best, as he has proven to be a draw in AEW. Ratings were higher and more stable when he was champion than when he wasn't. Roman IS a decently sized star given the current landscape, but they sacrificed almost everyone just to get him here. And that put WWE in far worse shape as a consequence. Seth of course, is the ultimate Jannetty. He has consistently failed every time he was on top
>>12946153The fucking delusion in here is prime. Seth's recent persona is cringe as all fuck, but Mox? His in ring work completely negates anything he does on the mic. Seth and Mox are literally inverses of each other. One is cringe on the mic but is able to work. The other is primo on the mic but throws kicks and punches like he is trying to assault you with literal air and not his body. They cancel each other out. Reigns has gotten a fucking clue on the mic. He is not going to be as cringe as Seth and he's not going to be as good as Mox, but he delivers. In ring, the same shit. He looks intimidating, can go, and doesnt throw punches and kicks like he is an autist faggot having a hissy fit. Plus he got the ding-dong diddly teeth.
>the distance between earth and the nearest dyson sphere
>>12948322>proven to be a drawHeadcannon
>>12948360>Business improves with person on topLiterally an objective measure of being a draw. In this case, TV ratings improved and STAYED improved through the majority of his title reign. Meanwhile, Roman was THE guy from 2015 to today, and 2.5+ million people decided that literally anything else was a better use of their time than Raw/SD
>>12946153Three shitters.
>>12948371Mox has never been a draw anywhere. From CZW, to WWE, to NJPW, to AEW.
Reigns > Mox = Rollins, I found those two equally shit.
>>12948387>Leaving out FCW, where he single handedly made people aware and interestedHis feud with Regal and Rollins actually made FCW matter enough that WWE decided to invest heavily in the developmental system
>>12948343Holy shit you are right.
>>12948371>objective measure of being a drawCitation needed
>>12948343>simping for ReignsHe's worse than both of them at what they're worst at. Fucker still can't even do a suplex.
>>12948401More headcannon, jfc
>>12948415sorry, meant to quote >>12948387
>>12948401>His feud with Regal and Rollins actually made FCW matter It didn't. I will give you those feuds were good, but it was because Regal and Seth were involved. Regal can match Dean for promos and can place him in a bookbag for an hour if needed and carry him to a match. Seth at that time was a work rate machine and could have made wrestling his shadow interesting. Dean is known for shit like pic related
>>12948414Reigns did a garbage backstage brawl match with Kevin Owens that made more sense and looked less cringe than Dean's fucking mouse traps on wood match with Omega. And Reigns' match had a fucking 20 minute botch to the finish. Dean's matches are all the same gimmick shit designed to hide the fact he cant work.
>>12948415No it's true zoom zoom zoom>>12948433>was good because Seth was involved>>12948448nice cognitive dissonance
>>12948462>nice cognitive dissonanceDon't use terms you dont understand.
>>12948490Bit rich coming from someone who uses the expression "can go" when referring to Reigns lol
>>12948535>Bit rich My subjective opinion of Reigns doesn't have anything to do with the objective fact you clearly have no idea what "cognitive dissonance" is.
>>12948588Literally every criticism of Mox you made applies equally, if not far worse, to Reigns but you refuse to reconcile this.>muh subjective opinionHere's an objective fact: (You) a bitch
>>12948608Mox >looks like shit>short>balding>weak>slow>unathletic >shit unbelievable promosRoman>looks great>tall>full head of hair>strong>quick>extremely athletic >interesting believable promosYa they are so much alike lol
>>12948641>Reigns>strongkek
>>12948608That's not cognitive dissonance.
>>12948433Clearly you weren't around at the time. Moxley was a much more hyped prospect at the time. Rollins was just the white meat babyface with a lot of potential, but Moxley was on another level.
>>12948659I’d like to see mox put up his numbers or even get a tryout with a cfl practice squad . He never would because he’s a cm punk esque non athletic YT boi wrestling geek mark
>>12948690>Gridiron Football is all athletes
>>12946153Honestly they're the posterboys for the huge decline the WWE had in the 2010s.
>>12948690I'd love to see Reigns actually hit a suplex on someone that doesn't make weight for 205 Live>>12948665Maybe. But (You) still a BITCH
>All these AEWtists trying to claim Mox is the best of the threeYou know, you can like a show without feeling the need to shill for EVERY part of that show.
>>12946153The three most influential wrestlers of this generation and it's not even close. These three are honestly on some anime shit with how they went on to basically be the main protagonist of the wrestling industry.All three of them will win PWI wrestler of the year back to back. Rollins was in 2019, Moxley was in 2020, and now Roman will be 2021. And that's a fucking spoiler. Screenshot this.
>Football and wrestling require the same exact skillsetsMight as well tell me Roman could hit off Prime Nolan Ryan better than Moxley because bigger arms
>>12948713I didn’t say that. You really think Mox isn’t CM Punk level non athlete Indy pussy?>>12948743He’s not cena or lesnar but everyone is small nowadays so he doesn’t often get to suplex anyone bigger than a cruiserweight
>>12946230WILL SOMEBODY PLEASE STOP THE DAMN MATCH
None of the three are good characters/promos. Seth is the best of the 3 in-ring and Moxley is the worst of the 3 in-ring.
>>12948776You used the CFL as some sort of athletic comparison. Brian Pillman was a NOSE TACKLE in the CFL, and he never once was big. Do you know what the average actual Nose Tackle looks like?
>>12948776He's been feuding with Owens for like 8 months>>12948762People have been saying Mox was the best of them since The Shield debuted, spurned drone
>>12948743ok
>>12948810Sorry, should've been more specific.>post leukemia returnDel Rio is there FFS
>>12948806You're right. I forgot that Mox was doing that garbage stuff he did in the Indys, so smarks would like that better than actual wresting.
>>12948762try harder faggot, the majority of the thread isn't saying that.
>>12948875All those words and ya said absolutely nothin'.
>>12946153Roman is the only one to ever draw a dime
>>12946153Dean Michaels, Seth Janetty and Roman Cassidy
rare case of 3 janettiesall 3 are anti dimes and killing the business, jack
>>12948343People here always claims Seth is good on the ring, but i've yet to remember one of his matches as nothing more than "good". DEAN at least can put memorable hardocore matches
>>12948641>>12948690>>12948810
Seth- Already Peaked. Failed as a babyface, but a solid main event heel. No need to put the belt on him again. Great Value AJ Styles. DEAN- Flopped in wwmeme, but is based in new japan and is doing well is aew. Will keep his spot for the foreseeable future. I just wanna see him and shooter as tag champs. Roman- finally in the spot he was destined to be in. It took them years to do it, but hes kino. Should be champ for a long long time
>>12946153Mox is the only one of the three who has entertained me in the last 2 to 3 years, Sef hasn't been good since 2015, and Ramen is always garbage.
>>12946204Well yeh, minus 1.5 million views is impossible...
>>129461531 thing we can all agree on?
>>12948803Damn no wonder Vince told keith to cover his chest
>>12950085based take here.
athletic ability, promos, the look.combine them into one wrestler and they would unironically be bigger than the rock
>>12950085This one is my favorite.
>>12952090I use POLYMERIZATION.>GASPSThat's right. Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, and Roman Reigns separately have their own strength and weaknesses but combined into one..
>>12946153Why is the ex WWE guy up front?
>>12946153Promos: Mox>>Reigns>>>>>>>>SethIn Ring: Seth>Reigns>MoxBooking: Mox/Reigns>>>>SethPhysical Look: Reigns>>Mox>SethReigns and Dean are close but Becky's husband sucks
Objectively Romans the biggest star and that’s all that really matters
>>12952324>In Ring: Seth>Reigns>MoxI disagree. Seff wrestles like a goddamn video game CAW. His shit makes no sense and is just one icon of Japanese wrestling's signature after another with none of the in-between that made them icons in the first place.Mox can't strike for shit but I'd still consider him a better worker than Roman simply because he doesn't have the godawful WWE style holding him back anymore.
>>12946153Jon > Seth > Roman
>>12946153Seff: big failure as a face and as a heel, even his matches lost their luster after that knee injury. his current gimmick is death and honestly him missing meant nothing.Mox: great fueds as a champion and mostly great to good matches. really felt like he carried the company through 2020. has a lot possible opponents so he's set as a main eventer.BIG DAWG: finally a heel, too bad it's 5 years too late, but is great in the role. he has zero credible babyfaces to face and the Owens feud just keeps going and going. if it continous the way it does people are gonna be sick of him real soon.
