[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

[Advertise on 4chan]


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Ranar.jpg (128 KB, 1200x901)
128 KB
128 KB JPG
Previous Thread >>82975640

>OFFICIAL Commander website, where you can learn the rules, see the current banlist, and read the format philosophy, laid down by the sellouts at the rules committee:
https://mtgcommander.net/

>What is EDH/Commander?
https://vocaroo.com/1ihc21gJLBh1

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet.
http://www.edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identity.
http://mtglands.com/

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choices.
http://www.tappedout.net

>CARD SEARCH
https://scryfall.com

>Proxy a deck or a cube for cheap
https://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM(embed)

>how to proxy using any printer
https://mtgprint.cardtrader.com/

>Thread Question/Prompt
You can errata one card. What do you change?
>>
File: fat1.jpg (111 KB, 660x495)
111 KB
111 KB JPG
What's your favorite color anon?
>>
>>
File: mh1-199-fallen-shinobi.jpg (182 KB, 672x936)
182 KB
182 KB JPG
>>82986345
>squirrels
Sure, thats who killed the thread
>>
Isn't this a slam dunk in Yuriko?
>>
>>82986145
> TQ
The Tarrasque has trample.
>>
>TQ
Add "this can only happen once per turn" to Chulane.
>>
>>82985093

Unironically running this on my Merieke Blink and its amazing.
>>
>>82986145
>TQ

Panoramas fetch non-basics.
>>
>>82986377
Yuriko is busted with topdeck manipulation.
That's kind of a given.

>>82986412
Based.
>>
>>82986427
>>82986412
>I'm just going to use my grixis panorama to grab cradle, no big deal
Worst decision from a flavour perspective.
>>
>>82986438
Cradle should be banned
>>
Which tribe is the more based of the rodentfags?
>>
>>82986145
>You can errata one card. What do you change?
Whip of Erebos no longer has a "sorcery speed" restriction
>>
File: blood moon.jpg (240 KB, 672x936)
240 KB
240 KB JPG
>>82986445
No land card should be banned. Just run targeted land destruction
>>
>>82986445
Just run a wrath and it's a land that doesnt make mana.
>>
File: 20220109_204331.jpg (823 KB, 1920x1440)
823 KB
823 KB JPG
>>82986163
>>82986317
>>82986452
>>
>>82986502
I kneel....
>>
>>82986502
Dude epic struggle is sick. Might run that in my Chatterfang. Do you run Snakepit based Chatterbro? Its a house in my deck
>>
>>82986503
Because of the speed of some of the Doom Blades, I'm doubt that second line.
I'll go ahead and try to cast Tortoise Formation much later, but if anyone has a counterspell beforehand, they can play that.
>>
File: _monog.png (5.72 MB, 2684x936)
5.72 MB
5.72 MB PNG
I'm a hopeless Ufag, what's there fun to be done in monog? I know I wanna play stuff like Dosan the Falling Leaf but I don't really have a plan from there.
>>
https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/feature/azusas-many-journeys-2022-01-14

>they made Azusa a gaywalker
>>
>>82986788
>https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/feature/azusas-many-journeys-2022-01-14

What icy plane did she go to? Khaldeim? Ice Age Dominaria?
>>
>>82986438
>search your library for an Island, Mountain or Swamp
>find cradle
It isn't even a Forest.
>>
>>82986163
White
>>
>>82986438
That's not what he meant, retard-kun
>>
File: 1642163197897.png (213 KB, 480x480)
213 KB
213 KB PNG
I have 5 mono W decks
>>
>>82986163
Big Black
>>
>>82986377
it is far better in Vega, the Watcher
>>
>>82986954
Commanders?
>>
>>82987059
8.5 tails, sram, darien, kenrith, brimaz
>>
File: shade's form.jpg (254 KB, 672x936)
254 KB
254 KB JPG
>>82986653
Depends on what you find fun, honestly. I've run a tons of different decks from high-powered ones like Seton storm to mid-power with Kamahl go-wide to pretty weak with Autumn Willow voltron. I've also run mono-G Anthousa spellslinger, Nemata control etc

>>82986163
Black will always have my favorite flavor (even if it's sucked for a decade now)
>>
>>82986954
Which commanders? And why
>>
>>82987076
>mono white kenrith

oof
>>
File: 1505684321797.jpg (12 KB, 210x216)
12 KB
12 KB JPG
>>82987076
>kenrith
>>
>>82987081
Nevermind>>82987076. Favorite one to run?
>>
>>82986949
>>82986901
then what did he actually mean
>>
>>82987083
>>82987088
Must be a former "MY MONO-W GOLOS DECK IS SPECIAL AND UNIQUE"fag
>>
>>82987080
>black is Le bad now
>still one of the best colors to see new cards
What lmao? Black does basically every single thing all the other colors do, more so than ever with Feed the Swarm
>>
>>82987103
Im going to hazard a guess and say it was a joke
>>
>>82987105
I want to like black but honestly, beyond tutors, there is not much that makes black special or better than other colours.
>>
>>82987105
Black is a top tier support colour, but on it's own it's pretty underpowered outside of ad naus brews.
>>
>>82987105
I was speaking primarily in a flavor sense but if we're going by power level, I'd say Blue and Green are firmly ahead of it and Red is closing in on 3rd.

>Feed the Swarm
That card is absolute dreck. I don't run it at any power level, regardless of cEDH or craw
>>
>>82987137
I run it in my pauper deck to deal with circle of protection red in my atog deck. Yes, it is horrible, but not 4c mana fixing in pauper horrible.
>>
>>82987164
Don't you have access to all colors in an atog deck? There are ton of other options to deal with enchantments outside black, or even with black with things like vindicate, if black is a prominent colour on your deck. Hell even chaos warp since you mention red.
>>
>>82987164
>>82987204
Shit sorry didn't read pauper.

Anyway thats maybe only where that card can be good, no shit.
>>
File: irini sengir.jpg (237 KB, 672x936)
237 KB
237 KB JPG
Leave enchantments to me
>>
File: mfwenchantments.png (14 KB, 62x72)
14 KB
14 KB PNG
>>82987227
>>
Hey guys im going to the store to pick up some bans, i think its time to get rid of mana crypt and those cast for free when has cmdr out cards
Need anything else?
>>
>>82987319
Should grab an English grammar book
>>
File: X5Qgr.jpg (573 KB, 1928x1528)
573 KB
573 KB JPG
>>82986788
>>82986883
Brother's War with Snow-Basics and a Azusa planeswalker card?
>>
>>82987080
Could you share your Nemata list? I'm thinking either I go for Nemata or Kamahl, using Kamahl to threaten MLD in response to a boardwipe.
>>
Is he actually gone?
>>
>>82987437
Just give it an hour.
>>
>>82987059
Teshar, Oswald, Livio, Yosei, Heliod God of the Sun
>>
File: changelings.jpg (752 KB, 976x680)
752 KB
752 KB JPG
Why run Ultimus instead of Moritte?
>>
>>
>>82987567
Simic is gay
>>
>>82987227
i love this bitch
>>
>>82986653
MonoG stax boiiiii
>>
Any fun tech for this dude? or am I really just bound to playing stax.
>>
>>82987677
>sultai
>>
>>82986954
>>82987076
>No Adeline, God-Eternal Oketra

I guarantee i'd stomp on you every time I only need mono w deck because i've perfected the art
>>
strionic resonator

lithoform engine

voltaic key
>>
I ordered a dark confidant for the highest cmc deck I’ve ever made.
Why am I so stupid
>>
>>82987709
>Adeline
Imagine running such a fuck ugly card
>>
replicating ring
>>
>>82987567
So you can play monoblue slivers and show how dope you are
>>
>>82987722
Yeah its ugly because it beats the shit out of you without any remorse and doesnt bother cleaning itself out
>>
File: 3517.png (12 KB, 368x142)
12 KB
12 KB PNG
>>
File: arboria.jpg (425 KB, 672x936)
425 KB
425 KB JPG
>>82987378
Kamahl is literally just mono-G good stuff. I've been playing Kamahl since I had a type-2 deck based around him back in the day

I don't have a list for Nemata but basically you slow the board down with control/stax effects and then shit out Saprolings to win the manner you so choose. I usually win with Helix Pinnacle.

Fun fact, generating tokens with Nemata still gives you protection using Arboria
>>
>>82987632
worthless card in the era of mana rocks
>>
is he any fun?
>>
>>82987829
>etb
Its pretty one dimensional but sure it can be fun if you're into that kind of thing
>>
>>82987829
Feels better as a support piece in Inalla.
>>
>>82987708
>fun
>>
>>82987887
I can only imagine how much more extra coping you have do losing to it then

>>82987925
Im strictly looking for Mono Blue Wizard tribal commanders
>>
>>82987677
I built him, if you're looking for the highest power version stax is really the only way to go. However I also had some success with some mid range stompy ideas thanks to B being so good at removal.
>>
>>82988012
I'm afraid it will, Anon.
>>
Anons, how do you embrace the craw? When I build decks I'm always looking to build them as efficient as possible. Not really cedh, but high power and reliable.

Recently a couple of members of my playgroup have mentioned my decks are a little too high power for the rest of the group.

How do you enjoy a lower power deck? I would get bored doing only 1-2 things a turn then passing, and not doing much till turn 4
>>
>>82988040
>italian-samurai
lmao
>>
>>82988040
how will they explain the fact that there were zero non-asian humans in kamigawa last time?
>>
>>82988041
Whisper reanimating the budget eldrazi like Ulamog's Crusher. If they can't beat that then just buy a precon.
>>
>>82988070
They wont have to, they'll just reprint some old kamigawa cards with new art featuring black and brown people
>>
File: an-zerrim face.png (54 KB, 638x576)
54 KB
54 KB PNG
>>82988021
>tribal
>>
>>82988070
explain?
>>
bought these all for under 200$... wtf
>>
File: 1600216166224.jpg (51 KB, 764x740)
51 KB
51 KB JPG
>>82988097
Oh no anon...
>>
>>82988097
>I bought a bunch of fake cards
Why are you bragging bro?
>>
>>82988097
>Logan Paul jpeg
>>
>>82986502
Foil cradle desu?
>>
>>82988097
Based proxychad.
The price for that card is mostly because of Modern. In my experience, the noncreature clause is a real problem for EDH.
>>
I'm thinking about converting my Yawgmoth into a Hapatra deck, because i want to rely less on combos and playing solitaire for 20 minutes. Thoughts? Because i'm using my Yawgmoth deck as a base i'd build her with a bunch of sacrifice stuff and hope to win by draining my opponents or using overrun effects on a bunch of snakes
>>
>>82988167
Ive found the opposite to be true desu swan song goes in all my U decks purealy because for 1 mana it fucks up the big players like cyc rift
>>
>>82988093
Yup. Is it hard for you to wrap your mind around people building commanders that aren't the top 100 on EDH rec or something?

>>82988115
The sentence was formed, if you had a hard time comprehending that has far more to do with your mental capacity. I wouldn't be surprised if you struggled - you probably earnestly believe Trump was cheated out of the election lol.
>>
>>82988167
>>82988137
>>82988112
>>82988097
Bought from TCGPlayer direct.
>>
>>82988209
Haha, yeah, TCGPlayer direct, LOL, *wink wink*! I got you, bro.
>>
>>82988167
>noncreature clause is a real problem for EDH.
wrong
>>
>>82988189
I'm not even american lol. You should realy see yourself through the eyes of non niggerworshiping countries.
>>
>>82988041
I feel you anon. what I do is that I try wincons that are wayyy out there or attempt to make the game int some weird lock. I pulled shared fate + eternal domination. I made an entire deck based on getting maze's end in a three color deck (before I realized that all gates needed different name). I even made a zubera combo deck !

those wore online decks because I don't have a huge collection but yeah. go for weird shit.
>>
>>82988172
>wants less combos
>builds hapatra
Shorter combos, maybe, but that's absolutely the wrong way to build hapatra. Why does it take you 20 mins to resolve a piss easy interaction? Like flip the top 30ish cards of your deck, and if you hit a tutor or blood artist you win?
>>
>>82988226
Check prices 1/7 MH1 12 copies... ill let you look.

>>82988249
Its hard to take you serious when you seem to think running a black-character as my mono white commander means i'm bending the knee or some dumb shit like that
>>
>>82988040
>venom snake's arm
>jetstream sam's faceshield/sword
>"now make him black, japanese, and from overwatch"
bravo kojima
>>
>>82988248
wrong place bro, but you made me nostalgic talking madolches. I had this crazy deck that would abuse eteleportation to get psychic earth-type tuner to the battlefield in order to make the naturia beast. It was just a very synergic and versatile deck, really fun to play.
>>
>>82988277
Yeah it is. Refusing to see why also is bending it.
>>
>>82988303
Oh right.. anything short of being a stormfag is bending it. Oh well, keep on coping ill keep winning virtually every deck with my commander :v)
>>
>>82988247
Eh, might just be my meta.

>>82988209
Receipts or it didn't happen.
>>
>>82988167
>>82988247
I'm going to second this opinion. I run this, force, swan song and a few other similar effects. Force of negation is nice in constructed because you can hardcast it, but the caveat of needing to be on someone else's turn really limits how useful it is to protect your own stuff, unless you can combo at instant speed, and noncreature means you absolutely need to be careful, unlike say force of will. Even swansong will pigeon hole you to an extent. Is it worth running? Yup absolutely, but it isnt the same thing as a regular counter. That being said, I specifically dont run fierce guardianship because if my commander is out, I should be in good shape to win, but getting it there is the hard part.
>>
>>82988322
see top half of
>>82988277
>>
>>82987076
Brimaz is the only based one
>>
>>82988167
>the noncreature clause is a real problem for EDH.
Fierce guardianship
>>
I hate that I’m saying this.
But I Hate Your Deck is pretty good when the professor isn’t on it
>>
>>82988568
Fuck that noise.
>>
>>82988097
>Obviously fake mana symbol
>>
>>82988277
Why would you buy fakes from tcg player, they're like $3 from Chinaman
>>
>>82988596
Professor and Posty are kino
>>
>>82988662
Posts is unironically pretty funny
>>
>>82988664
What's wrong with Rafiq?
>>
>>82988664
>UGx
>ever being non tranny
lol also rent free
>>
>>82987722
>Got mogged on by the bitch
Lol
>>
>>82988664
Every commander from the 2018 precon is both fuckable and playable
>>
>>82988596
can't tell if Prof is bad at Magic in general or just bad at EDH
>>
>>82988772
>le shiggy bald trooner
>>
File: Image (9).png (194 KB, 265x370)
194 KB
194 KB PNG
Pleasantly surprised every time this resolves.
>>
>>82987632
how would this work with world tree?
>>
File: 093122.jpg (1.73 MB, 1600x1200)
1.73 MB
1.73 MB JPG
>>82988149
Yes?
>>
>>82988978
based. If you foil something you do it right.
>>
>>82988209
>Lying on the internet
>>
>>82988844
Despite being a generic value commander, I think she'd be fun to pilot. Can't get past that atrocious art, however
>>
>>82988978
>>82989028
They should've left the set symbol unfoiled.
>>
File: peacekeeper.jpg (229 KB, 672x936)
229 KB
229 KB JPG
>>82988277
>when you seem to think running a black-character as my mono white commander
It's not even a cool black character. It's just an angry random black woman on a horse with no helmet on her way to raid your local Foot Locker
>>
>>82989151
I saw it as technology in vintage cube then put it in my deck and it's a house, especially with Eruth. It's part of my storm deck.
>>
File: HELL YEET.jpg (177 KB, 672x936)
177 KB
177 KB JPG
Are there any protection spells in red? Or am i stuck with Ricochet and equipment?
>>
Ok guys, i need a GOOD boros commander and i don't know if i build Koll or Winota, anyone here have any of those to comment about them?
>>
>>82989458
No comments on Koll but Winota is a commander that goes from 0 to "anyone have a boardwipe?" in a single turn.
Keep that in mind when deciding if that's the kind of deck you want to play.
>>
File: c20-50-deflecting-swat.jpg (182 KB, 672x936)
182 KB
182 KB JPG
>>82989451
This card is usually very good.
I'm against the "free if you controller a commander" spells, but I would make an exception for Etali
>>
>>82988844
I run her as a backup commander in Prosper. She's good
>>
>>82989451
>>82989518
Deflecting Swat is for literal homosexuals, same with any of the cards in that cycle.

Try Bolt Bend or Richochet Trap
>>
>>82988189
>>82988365
You need to go back.

>>82989493
Besides Winota, your options are limited, since Boros is either artifacts-and-equipment or combat 90% of the time (stuff like Firesong).
If you aren't building a Boros deck for an autistic "42 deck challenge" or as part of a bet or something, I would just bite the bullet and make it a three color since at least with something like Naya you have variance.
>>
>>82988040
When will Magic players file a class action lawsuit against WOTC for aggravated rape of an innocent plane?
>>
>>82989673
"Go back"? Ive been on 4chan for over 14 years now, despite your seething it will never be the perfect echo chamber you desire.

>>82989197
>It's not even a cool black character.
Who cares? A lot of newer commanders are generic as fuck. That's more of a result of the newer artwork than anything. People would complain regardless
>>
File: wulfgar.jpg (174 KB, 672x936)
174 KB
174 KB JPG
>>82990024
>A lot of newer commanders are generic as fuck
ENTER
>>
>>82990075
>>82990179
>its funny how many "If X would cause an ability to trigger, it triggers an additional time" commanders there are these days
I like them. It feels more like building a deck than building a commander.
You build the deck first and then there's this one card you can pull out at any time to buff everything else. As opposed to having one card you build around without which your deck doesn't even do anything.
>>
>>82990260
do thing twice isn't really interesting. Its the gee 2 hotdogs meme made real.
>>
>>82990260
>You build the deck first and then there's this one card you can pull out at any time to buff everything else.
How do you end up with a deck that has the same trigger and color identity as opposed to picking the commander and stuffing it with repeated effects?
I've never seen someone "accidentally" deckbuild into Yarok.
>>
>>82990373
He's probably the type of person that thinks cards like Yarok are good design.
>>
File: elbruswithengar.png (2.24 MB, 1341x935)
2.24 MB
2.24 MB PNG
>>82986145
>You can errata one card. What do you change?
Elbrus, the Binding Blade can be your Commander.
>>
File: ala-243-mountain.jpg (221 KB, 672x936)
221 KB
221 KB JPG
>>82986163
Red
>>
>>82990506
Totally fine at my table
>>
File: unh-128-time-machine.jpg (320 KB, 672x936)
320 KB
320 KB JPG
>>82987358
Wait a minute...
>>
>>82987713
I vote Resonator
>>
File: tsp-71-paradox-haze.jpg (206 KB, 672x936)
206 KB
206 KB JPG
>>82987727
If you could get it into play with both Paradox Haze and Sphinx of the Second Sun in play... it's probably still bad.
>>
>>82990506
I'd let you play an elbrus deck in a heartbeat.
>>
Wanna build a mono-Red deck, stuck between Zada, Neheb, or Subira. Any anons with experience with them, what did you like/dislike? Any special spice that goes with them? Memorable stories at the table?
>>
>>82990661
Zada is easy fun and cheap.
>>
>>82989638
>Deflecting Swat is for literal homosexuals, same with any of the cards in that cycle
Sounds like sour grapes to me, didn't buy any before the price spike?
>>
>>82990690
Not him but soul ring is also a faggot card that should be banned in the format.
Are you going to call sour grapes on that one too?
>>
>>82990690
I just buy one of each sealed product and do MODO set redemption. Can't miss out that way
>>
>>82990697
I'm mostly going to laugh at your terrible taste. What do you like?
>>
>>82990690
>liking reddit cards
Sounds like sour grapes to good taste. You enjoying the shit you eat is fine, stop trying to infect others with it.
>>
>>82990718
>What do you like?
Cards that aren't auto-includes in every deck.
>>
>>82990697
>soul ring
Kek
>>
>>82990718
The only deck I've liked in recent memory has been Kambal or Haktos.
Laugh away if you must.
>>
File: 1641682522743.jpg (135 KB, 640x615)
135 KB
135 KB JPG
>>82990732
>hates basic lands
the fucking state of /edhg/
>>
File: khm-8-divine-gambit.jpg (158 KB, 672x936)
158 KB
158 KB JPG
>>82990742
>next leveled me instantly
fair play
>>
File: jindershanky.jpg (67 KB, 1200x675)
67 KB
67 KB JPG
>>82990749
Based and Khalipilled
>>
File: file.png (40 KB, 469x412)
40 KB
40 KB PNG
>>82990736
Soul ring would also be ban worthy if it existed.
>>
>log on to mtgo to play a game
>yuriko
>sram
>glissa
>sram and glissa refuse to block or play removal
>i boardwipe twice
>die
Shit game desu
>>
>>82990742
>Laugh away if you must
My parents raised to not make fun of the retards so I can't
>>
>>82990784
The amount of edh games I end up in that are actually 2 headed giant but only 1 team knows on modo is really annoying. You run into people playing complimentary decks often and then in gameplay they straight up help each other out.
>>
>>82990801
That's too bad. Self-deprecating jokes are very useful to have in ones arsenal.
>>
>>82989638
>any of the cards in that cycle
Not playing them is bad for your deck despite them being bad for the format
>>
>>82990801
My parents beat me regularly. Its ruined every relationship I've had in life. At least I have my magic cards and online friends.
>>
>>82990820
I'm fine lessening my own deck's win ratio to make the game as a whole better.
>>
>>82990842
It's also ok for you to stop whining like a bitch but here you are
>>
>>82990866
Whining?
Saying I'm okay not playing a card is whining? Let me guess, you think I'm the same anon?
>>
>>82990690
Playing around interaction by looking at available mana and cards in hand is one of the things I really liked about magic. Feels bad to be punished despite proper assessment. Its an "oh shit" button for people with bad foresight, but its good so not playing the card isnt really an option.
>>
>>82990866
It's ok to be homosexual and play homosexual cards, anon. Doesn't mean people have to like you though.
>>
>>82990885
Perfectly valid.
>>
>>82990842
I find most people tend to agree, that also leaves an opening for people without social skills to style on you using their wallets.
I hate that feeling.
>>
>>82990742
Do you still have a windgrace list?
>>
>>82990885
>Playing around interaction by looking at available mana and cards in hand
Lol too bad
>>
>>82990916
I'm indifferent to it. People that need to "style" on others with their hobbyist purchases have deep rooted self esteem issues. It is what it is but I'm not a bad enough person to try and widen the gulf between us even further.
>>
>>82990842
You wouldnt need to do that if you played competent people.
>>
File: 1641468586228.png (587 KB, 653x826)
587 KB
587 KB PNG
>built Karador
>Threw in classic Reveillark + Karmic Guide so I can loop Ichor Rats into a proliferate creature for the win
Damn, that's some 2013 mood right there
>>
>>82990947
>need to
I play magic because its fun. I don't get the weird attempt to pull a holier than thou attack for a game played for fun.
You do though, which is weird.
>>
>>82990916
>style on you using their wallets
That's fine I have another reserve list card I'll play next turn.
>>
>>82990885
>Feels bad to be punished despite proper assessment. Its an "oh shit" button for people with bad foresight

>I cast despark to exile thing
>ok in response I cast heroic intervention
Might as well ban hexproof and indestructible then
>>
>>82990916
>style on me with your cardboard while sitting at my mahogany table I made with my bare hands
weak flex but you do you champ
>>
>>82990985
>Might as well ban Heroic Intervention
nta, but why not both? That card should have been white. Green has enough tools.
>>
>>82990881
Don't care who you are faggot, your post just reeked of whining
>>
>>82991016
More like you made the same mistake you make daily here. You can't stay a newfag forever my dude.
>>
>>82991007
>Heroic Intervention is more white than green
More green hexproof cards exist, white is more close to protection from color
>>
File: 1639685010891.png (148 KB, 417x423)
148 KB
148 KB PNG
>>82991024
>get called a faggot
>deflect
>get called a faggot again
>haha get baited m8
sure bud
>>
>>82990985
>without paying its costs
>>
File: bai.jpg (57 KB, 680x324)
57 KB
57 KB JPG
>>82991058
Just take the L and move on with your pathetic life.
>>
>>82991061
There are multiple cards that can be played without paying a mana cost but why do the ikoria commander cards trigger you over those ones?
>>
>>82991080
why are you posting about yourself? Seems like something a retard would do
>>
>>82991082
Probably the referencing your commander part. Its so blase for commander, imagine a magic card having extra functionality as long as you were playing magic. Its just dumb.
Its a conceptual argument retards have trouble wrapping their heads around so they just get angry and resort to name calling when you spell it all out for them.
>>
>>82991118
I wonder if opal palace triggers people
>>
>>82991157
You know for a fact it doesn't.
>>
File: texplainthejoke.jpg (129 KB, 674x510)
129 KB
129 KB JPG
>>82991162
But its a made for commander card
>>
>>82991082
>There are multiple cards that can be played without paying a mana cost
And they usually come with substantial downsides but not that cycle
>>
File: timeless_witness.jpg (256 KB, 1200x858)
256 KB
256 KB JPG
>>
>>82991195
its shit and not a blatant power increase for the format
The standard response from seasoned mtg players is to roll with the punches even if its bad for the game, this is a good thing but it also tends to lead to being ok with a lot of bullshit. Take your pick.
>>
>>82991195
Its also just a land. You are falling into anon's assumption that the people that can't understand the conceptual argument just start stomping their feet acting retarded.
What a shame.
>>
>>82991195
If you don't get it you don't get not much use explaining it to a remedial type.
>>
File: cmr-337-scroll-rack.jpg (170 KB, 672x936)
170 KB
170 KB JPG
>>82986377
It's not bad. Any form of topdeck manipulation is good for her. But nothing is quite the slam dunk for her as using Scroll Rack to repeatedly punch the table with Draco.
>>
>>82990972
The most fun games are close competitions with an evenly matched opponent. If you dont have one, look to solve the problem. Your weird passive aggressive story has no bearing.
>>
>>82991478
He is solving the problem. A handicap results in an evenly matched opponent.
>>
>>82991478
>strawman: the post
kek okay
>>
>>82991478
He appears to want the most evenly matched game
>I'm fine lessening my decks win ratio
He's punching down and letting the other guy have a fair shot by not being a shitter. And its making you really upset for some reason.
>>
>>82991478
It really is a thread full of your betters humoring you when they don't have to lol. Get your shit together dude. My wife calls it touching grass or something like that.
>>
>>82991551
It isn’t really punching down if you let the other guy have a fair shot. That’s just leveling the playing field.
>>
He didn't choose the Thug Life
The Thug Life chose him
>>
>>82991588
Yes. The better player is leveling the playing field for the worse player. That presupposes that one is more superior to the other.
>>
>>82991627
But by leveling the playing field, it ceases to be punching down. Punching down is conceptually tied to the continued presence of the differential.
>>
>>82991670
And the differential is still in play even with the gracious efforts of anon. Being uplifted solidifies who is the top dog instead of muddying who it is.
Under your reasoning the motto of "standing on the shoulders of giants" would lose its meaning.
>>
Everyone can tell my proxies are fake and won't let me play them/play with me. I used the links at the top of this thread.... idk...
>>
>>82991670
>beggar receives alms from well to do man
>beggar now thinks the well to do man is somehow less his better through this act of kindness
The power dynamic has solidified and deepened, not smoothed itself over.
>>
>>82991713
Technically speaking, by an infinitesimal amount, that’s true: the economic divide between the two has been lessened, ever so slightly.
>>
>>82991704
Yeah proxies are never as good as the real thing and like 98% of players use real cards so get a job and start collecting.
>>
>>82991695
“Standing on the shoulders of giants” is completely orthogonal to the concept. That’s about how subsequent scholars gain a head start by having access to the work of their predecessors, not some kind of question of competition.
>>
>>82991727
The economic divide is not considered. The mere mention by you shows the gulf in understanding. The money means nothing. It means so little that the well to do man gave it away without a second thought.
>>
>>82991704
Typically the issue is less about your cards being real or fake and more about which cards you proxied
What did you build with MPC?
>>
>>82991749
Correct. The persistence of the expression shows his understanding of interpersonal dynamics isn't how it really works. If it worked his way that expression would not still hold the same meaning today as when it was coined.
>>
>>82991755
every mythic, every fetchland, the power 9, medallians, signets, shocks, and Bronze Sable
>>
>>82991704
>everyone can
but they won't, no one cares. People that would commit actions that would ostracize them from their playgroup will still do the same regardless.
>>
File: ths-212-bronze-sable.jpg (162 KB, 672x936)
162 KB
162 KB JPG
>>82991782
Nice
>>
>>82991799
The proxies are getting me ostracized because they don't look real and they smell like chemicals and farts
>>
>>82991799
>no one cares
I know an entire local game store population and play group that would disagree with you anonymous 4channer speaking for everyone
>>
>>82991845
>>82991867
Sounds like a personal problem.
>>
>>82991867
Hey, at least he spoke for just us 30 guys and your 30 airplane mode ips instead of an entire town's game store.

I don't care about your proxies.
>>
>>82991867
What town? I travel for work and I'd be willing to do some investigatory research.
>>
File: wrong_turn.jpg (143 KB, 960x704)
143 KB
143 KB JPG
>>
>>82991958
whats nicole apex doing in a libary?
>>
Oh god he riled the proxy children again
>>
File: shm-222-vexing-shusher.jpg (287 KB, 672x936)
287 KB
287 KB JPG
>>82991958
Sir, this is a library. Please stop snarling so loudly.
>>
>>82991985
its not hard
>>
>>82991985
No one cares we don't play with him.
>>
>>82991985
Is that how you see it lol?
>>
Holy shit proxyfags are FRAGILE
>>
>>82992078
Is that how you see it lol?
>>
File: upo2ckb7mjs21.png (250 KB, 375x523)
250 KB
250 KB PNG
>>82986163
Purple
>>
>>82992126
>typeless basic land
>>
>>82991704
hAHAHAHHAHA. You paid for illegitimate cardboard? HAHAHHAHAHAHAHA
>>
File: wcnqtq65sjs21.png (1.82 MB, 1125x1569)
1.82 MB
1.82 MB PNG
>>82992169
As cool as I think that Purple would have been, the fact that it would have had to interact with the other colours, and would have fucked up the colour combinations means I really feel like it's probably a good thing it never ended up going through, and that the Eldrazi-style colourless cards are probably the best representation of a "sixth colour". Still, it would have been interesting to see what Purple would have been like.
>>
>>82992231
Purple IS butthole mana. The only other alternative would be energy to sidestep the "has to interact with the other colors" mindset.
I'd rather have the butthole mana.
>>
>>82992231
Colorless is functionally perfect as the 6th color except for it being named colorless but thats a very small problem. Its a shame the eldrazi stuff was handled so terribly, on a longer timeline it would have been a great addition to the game.
>>
>>82991617
What soundtrack do you think he has on that disk? What would Nevinyrral listen to?
>>
>>82992304
Thriller
>>
>>82992304
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-06Mt8oDA_E
>>
>>82992304
36 chambers of shaolin
>>
>>82992304
Blind Guardian - Nightfall In Middle Earth
>>
>>82992304
1 of the umpteen albums Biggy's family released years after his death.
>>
File: $41.35.jpg (223 KB, 672x936)
223 KB
223 KB JPG
>Glory was gone; Glory was everywhere.
>>
How good are the two crimson vow precons? I've got a heavily modified Aesi deck from one of the previous precons but i fancy a change. I'm super new to magic and have only ever played that one deck.
>>
>>82992528
The vampire one is garbage. Spirit one is apparently not too bad
>>
>>82992471
>$45
Fuck I should've bought more than 10 when they were only 5 each
>>
>>82992528
Vampires needs a good upgrade
Spirits also needs a few more spirits, but it slaps hard
It's also a nice Azorius deck that can be played with going full control, so there's that
>>
>>82992543
>>82992579
The Spirits one is also probably going to be turbocharged by Kamigawa, so there's that.
>>
It's still a fun deck my dudes:)
>>
>>82992706
I certainly enjoy it. I flavored the deck to be as close to a continual reference to lovecraft's stories as I could, His cat included
>>
File: 1527177855158.jpg (45 KB, 282x235)
45 KB
45 KB JPG
>>82992706
>tribal
>exile mill
>>
>>82992753
I haven't found space for the cat yet but it seems good. Mine is secretly lantern tribal
>>
>>82992634
Would you suggest getting the spirits or just wait to see any new precons? Also is the spirit deck fast to play? My Aesi deck is super countered by anything that can kill me before I get 15 mana
>>
File: 1627866596485.png (306 KB, 509x423)
306 KB
306 KB PNG
>>82992759
>his entire deck hinges on a keystone that daddy umbris might passively exile
>>
>>82992471
Its seriously one of the best cards in all ways.
>amazing art
>amazing mechanics
>amazing flavor text
It is truly greater than the sum of its parts, and its parts were all 10/10.
>>
>>82992852
This expression feels slightly off, learn the language before mouthing off your bants.
>>
>>82992852
Wow, sounds weak even in your own words!
>>
>>82992901
you on the left
>>
>>82992916
>I'll insult him by claiming he is the strongest warrior to ever live
terms accepted. Your concession is too sportsfan.
>>
>>82992948
okay I laughed
>>
>>82992852
Noooo please don't exile maybe 1 or 2 out of 6 wincons by playing janky creatures, I could conceivably lose to that if I got mana flooded or something
>>
File: 1da.jpg (46 KB, 529x785)
46 KB
46 KB JPG
>>82992948
esoteric bants
>>
File: ody-149-mindslicer.png (1.65 MB, 745x1040)
1.65 MB
1.65 MB PNG
>>82993061
>6 wincons
that message wasn't for you anon. also
>horrors
>janky
>>
>>82993084
Yes, that card is janky. Are you also running a tertiary Hellbent theme?
>>
I'm glad I found one of these bad boys when I was sorting some bulk. I wish there were more effects like this and back to basics.
>>
>>82993084
This was the first rare I played and realized that the downside of black rares wasn't always a downside.
Damn this brings back memories.
>>
>>82993133
I reanimate pic related for my mana fucking plans most of the time. For some reason my group is fine with it but most other forms of messing with mana isn't accepted in the group.
>>
>>82993168
That's because it's slow and has no built in protection. Still cool, but not Kuro Pitlord cool.
>>
>>82993133
This is much slower but an option for U players. Double points if its a no blue group.
>>
>>82987126
Damn, anti-black guy is still in these threads?
>beyond the most powerful effect in the game and the best wincons like they don't DO much tho lmao
>>
>>82987632
>6cmc to do nothing
>tap my dorks and rocks, win
>>
How do you feel about ramp spells that require you to sacrifice a land in order to put two lands onto the battlefield? Specifically in a (RG) deck that doesn't run Crucible of Worlds.
>>
>>82993578
meh...
what are you aiming to accomplish ?
>>
>>82993578
They are really good in decks with 3+ colors and you want to correct your mana base and maybe you have some way to get them back from the gy or have some sacrifice positive interactions, it really depends on your build.
>>
>>82993827
Why would you combo those cards together?

>>82993578
Scapeshift is absolutely 10/10 amazing.
>>
File: znc-93-living-twister.jpg (162 KB, 672x936)
162 KB
162 KB JPG
>>82993578
Depends how deep you go down that route. For basic ramp spells you have better options but RG has an elemental theme and a bunch of them mess around with lands. If you want to durdle its an option. There are enough ways to pay off what you're doing, maybe.
>>
File: 1641768093770.jpg (178 KB, 672x936)
178 KB
178 KB JPG
>>82992126
while the swastica land is rockin'
there is a better chance of a "unset" that uses purple with 4 other colors that spoof the originals...
purple - caves
yellow - deserts
brown - mud ... er... mudslides
teal - oceans (fuck you blue... 'island' pptttt)
grey - glaciers
>>
>>82991958
Looks like concept art for a Spyro enemy
>>
>>82993893
A parallel reality set with all the wackiest this would never work in magic set would have been much better than the outrageous experiments the real game has had to suffer recently.
>>
File: R14kkDj.png (13 KB, 657x527)
13 KB
13 KB PNG
I still don't understand how the errata of ranar ever watchful changes anything. The text says the same thing but in a different order, does that really affect things that much? Pls explain
>>
>>82993071
explain this image
>>
>>82994398
Gtfo newfag
>>
>>82994201
A replacement effect is not in itself a "spell or ability," so Ranar now only triggers if the EFFECT of a separate spell or ability you control would then result in a permanent being exiled. Since it has to be part of the effect, Skullclamping tokens doesn't count (because they're sent to the graveyard/exile as a state-based action, not as the effect of a spell or ability you control), nor does sacrificing something to Phyrexian/Ashnod's altar (because the creature is sent to the graveyard/exile as a cost, not as the effect of a spell or ability you control).
>>
File: 1635648674931.png (1.05 MB, 670x930)
1.05 MB
1.05 MB PNG
>>82994201
no idea, and i dont have the card on mtgo... (which i use to get some interractions and rules clarified).
maybe the rest in peace combo is now null and void...
dunno.
might be the banishing foreskin vs oblivion o-ring
>>
30 starting life is objectively superior to 40
>>
File: 1639876606428.jpg (313 KB, 672x936)
313 KB
313 KB JPG
>>82994505
sweet !
welcome
now where the fux is -pits- guy
>>
>>82994523
I dont post unless pits have been posted sry
>>
>>82994541
>>82994488
>>
File: 1628212838469.jpg (189 KB, 672x936)
189 KB
189 KB JPG
>>82994541
i wonder if i hold such summoning ?
>>
>>82994566
non visible pits breh
>>82994574
she still wearing sleeves
>>
>>82993578
land type in graveyard, lands in play from library
>>
Have they reprinted caucasian people in White yet?
>>
>>82994845
kek
>>
Be honest
Did you know this card existed?
How much jank is going to be buried in time due to constantly releasing product?
>>
>>82988167
Braindead
>>
>>82990885
>gee, Force of Will has been a staple in everything it's legal in for 20 years and I can't fathom my opponent having that in hand
Seems like you're just a retard unfortunately. When I'm playing legacy or commander, it's safe to presume an opponent might have a FoW if they have two cards in hand and all lands tapped. This has to be a bait post, no fucking way.
>>
>>82994954
I literally looked at every single commander ever printed today. Eruth is the spice. Realized this after an excellent legacy showing.
>>
>>82990781
>Soul Ring
>2WUBRG
>Artifact - Equipment
>Equipped creature gets +6/+2
>Sacrifice equipped creature: Add {150} to your mana pool. Other players can't play spells or activate abilities for ten seconds. At the end of those ten seconds, lose 170 life. Effects that prevent or redirect damage cannot be used to counter this loss of life.
>>
If you're not proxying every card and playing only izzet noncreature spells wtf is wrong with you
>>
>>82994996
I've opened the proxy floodgates at my LGS and now everyone and their mother play with proxied decks. Feels great since they still support the shit out of the store as well.
>>
>>82994996
Bruh I'm too busy blood mooning myself and killing the table with animate dead worldgorger and valakut
>>
>>82988041
Literally as easy as just swapping your non-basic lands for shittier versions.

You can keep the rest of the deck the same.
>Fetchlands? Yeah Terramorphic and Evolving wilds.
>Dual lands? Yep all the guild gates.
>>
>>82995123
Nah. You should use expensivr enablers for jank wincons. It's the true path of fun.
>>
>>82994981
>not understanding the drawback and ability to playing around force of will
WEEWW
>>
>>82994996
I'm playing slobad, some of my cards aren't proxies.
>>
>>82989451
Pyroblast, red blast, swat.
>>
>>82988041
Find a new group; you won't enjoy playing neutered.
>>
>>82994981
Ive been playing some form of legacy pox for the last decade, the difference between pitching one card to counter a spell and two cards is huge.
That being said the fewer free counters they print the better, we certainly do not need a critical mass of playable free counterspells, gladly we aren't there yet but who knows what the future holds.
>>
>>82989451
All instant speed copy spells are psudo counterspells
Also be red
Be fast
Sometimes fall on your face its ok
>>
>>82995499
>legacy pox
Oh shit that's cool. I'm a spanish inquisition player who moved on to doomsday and various meme storm brews.
>>
>>82995510
Does your deck still function? Mine has lost a lot of its bite recently as it turns out escape is really powerful. Ive gone as far as to mainboard gravehate and at that point I kinda feel like my deck is going the way of enchantress.
>>
>>82994983
>the next 10 spells you cast cannot be countered
>>
>>82994954
If they're insisting on giving us only Female Pirate legends, can they at least be hot?
>>
>>82994954
I want to go back to seeing more jank edh decks
>>
File: 1609971157183.jpg (103 KB, 480x480)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
>>82995035
>thinking a store can survive off of food & beverage sales alone
>>
>>82994954
Yes, I remember the feeling of disappointment when I pulled it.
>>
New, migrate whenever >>82996298



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.