[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/mlp/ - Pony


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.




File: large.png (916 KB, 675x1024)
916 KB
916 KB PNG
How is the comic?
>>
is this the one with discord? it's bad
>>
>IDW
Probably bad.
>>
inb4 500 replies, 90% of which is just two schizos arguing
>>
>>38754698
Saw the screencap with Discord, didn't read a single page.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EiOBq1jNvDY
>>
>>38754698
thought it was pretty cool, it's not revolutionary or anything special but it's alright plus it brings back one of my favorite characters and reveals a bit of what happened before G5 even though it was executed quite poorly. Most are just seething about G5 being a thing. MLP is taken way too seriously, it's just a cartoon for children.
>>
>>38754698
Has some good bits of humour but otherwise really don't like the direction they are going
>>
>>38754698
They took the biggest mystery of the G5 world and immediately explained it, thus removing any reason to speculate, theorize, or discuss it.
It means that whoever wrote it has absolutely no idea how to write engaging stories or build a world. I just hope that the show contradicts it so it can be safely disregarded.

It also means that they're going to run out of ideas in about 5 issues at this rate.
>>
>>38754808
Literally who
>>
>>38754838
Yes.
>>
One of the worst things to happen to pony in recent years was IDW Publishing keeping the rights to the MLP comics.
>>
It was alright, though it continued the fad of making the M6 act retarded, but i think it was a bit excessive for the writers to add that discord had a foal with fluttershy
>>
>>38754698
It's alright. The threads, however, are hilarious. It's like visiting a local mental ward and watching the schizos ramble incoherently for hours.
>>
>>38754698
The first issue was good. The second issue was bad.
>>
>>38754698
better than the way IDW ended g4
>>
>>38754739
>>38754705
Wait what, there's fucking Discord in it?
No way it's not ultra kino then, come on
>>
>>38755887
you can read it here some anon posted the whole thing in a thread https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/38750374/
>>
better than S10/10
>>
>>38755929
>G4: comics look like shit, show looks amazing
>G5: comics look amazing, show looks like shit
truly boggles the mind
>>
File: discordideee.jpg (241 KB, 758x765)
241 KB
241 KB JPG
>>38755887
All discord does is go "I want to destroy all magic so ponies will stop being racist, but fuck, That's probably a bad idea so I won't do it unless you TELL me its okay to do it!"
>>
>>38756761
Sounds pretty good to me, I'll keep reading later
>>
>>38754698
It's better than most G4 comics so far, though that's not exactly a high bar. I just hope they can stick the landing because that's something IDW has consistently had a problem with.
>>
>>38754698
It's bad but it's by far the best G5 content out there. Though, that's really just saying this pile of shit smells the least.
>>
Izzy's cute in em
>>
It already contradicts MYM (which is the main series) if you care about that sort of thing.
>>
>>38756912
I liked the movie quite a bit before it went to shit in the second half.
Hate the shows tho, but this comic's pretty good
>>
>>38757956
Do you know what gives it away?
>Xxxxx, but
>X, but
>I X, but
>I X as much as anyone else, but
Scram you kike menace
>>
>>38758143
I liked s08-s09, but I can agree that it had some serious flaws. I can understand people who hate them.
>>
>>38758153
You're fucked in the head and dragging the quality of life for the average human being down with you
>>
>>38755023
Dude look, they started! >>38758156
>>
Not nearly as bad as some people are pretending, and bit as good as some shills are claiming. Like most things MLP, it's fine. Could be better, but fine.
>>
>>38758180
>, but
>>
>>38758181
What forced meme is this, someone spoonfeed me
>>
>>38758184
It's the resident shizo. Just wait until he rants with "you're being dishonest".
>>
>>38758156
>>38758143
meds
>>
>>38758203
He'll never get em
>>
File: 1655604108094.png (239 KB, 271x349)
239 KB
239 KB PNG
>>38754698
The M5 are considered cute and in-character in it, but the poorly written story doesn't make sense and adds mostly problems to G5's world building. It's contradictory to both G4 and G5, and it remains unknown how canon the G5 comics are to G5, and whether jarring inconsistencies will also occur in the series. I'm surprised that a lame and ooc Discord is the least offensive part of the story, kek.
>>38754825
This. Either we just learned everything in the blandest way, or if it's all a lie, it needs to be rectified by revealing everything in the blandest way. The intrigue is gone without adding anything to G5 Equestria's world.
It's also questionable how knowledgeable Sunny is on FiM lore; here she appears to already know everything, whereas in the G5 movie, it was merely a loose understanding that there used to be some kind of mostly forgotten pony utopia ages ago.
>>38755023
Hilarious for the first day or two, but it gets tiresome fast. When I have nothing better to do, I look into G5 content, but it can't inspire me to get invested. When discussing it, it's always
>two more weeks until the REAL G5 starts, just wait and seeee, don't judge a book by its cover even though we're a movie, a mini series, a comic and a pilot into the show.
Weird how G4 inspired millions on first sight, weird that books put much care into their first chapters because those decide on whether or not a reader gets hooked or puts a book away for good, weird that fruit is eaten when ripe and not earlier. First impressions can be deceiving, but they're still a taste test. G5 is one bland candy and most that can be done to improve it is add sprinkles or some filling but the base candy isn't to my liking; not bad enough to spit it out but I'm not gonna chew another because there's Haribo, Ferrero, Lindt etc. all around me to choose from instead.
>>
Considered by who
>>
>"G5's equestria world"
What is that?
>>
What else is there to choose from?
Where?
>>
>>38758898
>>38758894
>>38758900
calm down schizo man
>>
>>38758143
>You HAVE to think of everything in black and white like me!!
G5 sure brings out the autistic manchildren from the woodwork
>>
>>38760370
It's definetly noticealbe. I've noticed a pretty big uptick in schizos since the movie dropped.
>>
>>38754698
>How is the comic?
It's not G4 so I automatically hate it
>>
>>38760958
That's quite a shitty mindset to have
>>
>>38760958
So you liked all the G4 comics?
>>
>>38758143
>if you qualify any statement ever you're a jew
How do you schizos manage to feed and clothe yourselves, let alone figure out how to use the internet?
>>
>>38754813
Woah there friend, don't you know liking anything about le g% is bad? You must consoom past and only past because if you want happy, you woke and must die. raeg raeg raeg

(I know this is retarded, but this sums up 90% of the people bullshitting around here. I'll agree the story is shit, but the people hating G5 for not being G4 are fucking stupid.)
>>
>>38760958
>>38760370
>>
>>38761759
Some of them must be baiting
I refuse to believe
>>
>>38760958
How the hell did you come here if you have such a closed mind
>>
>>38762816
You get updoots, retweets and all that shit by declaring your side. Remember that everything is black and white and everyone who doesn't agree is an enemy.
>>
>>38754698
It's shit
>>
>>38762828
I didnt mean it that way
How the hell can someone who decided to give a shot to MLP reject something solely because it aint G4
>>
>>38754838
Yes.
>>
>>38755887
Its shit. Discord is OOC on the level of Luke Skywalker in Last Jedi so the comic itself mostly shit on Discord depicting him as a lonely miseerable loser and Twilight as some tyrant who disabled the magic in Equestria
>>
>>38763429
>lonely miseerable loser
Could be the death of fluttershy plus all the time that's passed has changed him
I haven't read it yet so maybe it's handled badly, but just reading "he's a lonely miserable loser" sounds like a kino development to me
>>
>>38763434
he also likes animals now
>>
>>38763434
He should be either raisinng his and Fluttershy kids if he was romantic with her or if he wa platonic he should be living happy life of being a NEET chaos master with Smooze like Timon and Pumba. Not being an old crazy mad living in dark ruins of Equestria. This is the worst possible ending for him. He isnt some side literal who character who can be portrayed as miserable because we dont know him. This is like portraying Spike as suicidal virgin who never scored with Rairty, Gabby or Smodler and killed himself alone in a cave. This is some bullshit fanfic AU scneario that they want to sell as canon
>>
File: dicksword getting CAGED.jpg (138 KB, 1200x680)
138 KB
138 KB JPG
>>38764246
>This is the worst possible ending for him.
Sounds unironically great. I haven't read the comic but now I want to.
>>
>>38764236
based animal enjoyer
>>
>>38754698
fucking sucks like everything mlp related on the last 3 years.
>>
>>38754698
Better than what i expected when my standards are for 6 years old, but the sentencing feels weird and too scripted?
>>
>>38765495
The movie was good
>>
>>38763434
Do you even listen to yourself talk?
>>
>>38763353
Because it violently destroys the future of g4
>>
>>38766231
I like the destruction of G4
Twilicorn's policy was shit and glad it turned out it was a disaster.
ponies deserve that. I can watch Equestria burn.
>>
>>38766235
Basado
>>
>>38766228
Are you even able to form an argument?
>>
>>38767608
No
>>
>>38754698
>Seeing a destroyed and ruined cantorlot
>Discord talking about Fluttershy a ton
>Discord taking care of small animals
Fuck man it shouldn't of made me shed one tear.
I'm curious to see where it goes but I wish we got this animated instead
>>
>>38769782
Same
>>
>>38769782
>shouldn't of
>>
>>38754698
it's another
>muh racism
plotline
at least discord's looking fine
>>
>>38770524
I do wonder if its gonna be more of it when we see her again or if her racism was just a means to an end
>>
>>38770429
Kek.
>>
Is there any more issues? Yayponies only has 1 and 2 but ive seen a cover for issue 5 already, kinda interested in the plot.
>>
>>38771489
There's only these two. They've released covers for them far earlier, but that's about it.
>>
>>38766235
Based
>>
>>38771129
Who knows
One can only hope
>>
>>38771129
>Her racism
The comic wasnt about Posey
>>
>>38774017
How many plots about racism has g5 had so far, every single one why is that?
>>
>>38774070
Best guess is Hasbro has decided this is the forever problem of g5 just like megatron is to transformers
>>
>>38774070
>Sisters Take Flight: the royal sisters leave Zephyr Heights, but they have each other
Clearly about racism.
>A Home to Share: turns out you can do things better if you use some coordination
Definitely about racism.
>Zipp Gets Her Wings: Zipp learns they joy of teaching others to do their best
Yep, racism.
>Nightmare Roommate: don't try to imitate your friends, because that's not why they liked you to begin with
Literally racism.
>Welcome to Mane Melody: difficulties can have an easier solution if you stay calm
Jesus Christ, calm it down with the racism.
>The Unboxing of Izzy: being with your friends is fun by itself
Fucking racism, man.
>Foal Me Once: sometimes the solution to a mystery is right before your eyes
Racism.
>Clip Trot: just because something is popular doesn't mean you have to do it too
Another episode about racism.
>It's T.U.E.S. Day: don't forget to save some time to celebrate friendship with your friends
The very definition of racism.
>Sunny-Day Dinners: I SAID, DON'T FORGET TO SAVE SOME TIME TO CELEBRATE FRIENDSHIP WITH YOUR FRIENDS
Racism one more time.
>Maretime Bay Day 2.0: doing things with your friends is better than recording them for your social media
Racism again.
>The Game Is A Hoof: check under your pillow before accusing your roommates of stealing your stuff
Cleverly disguised plot about racism.
>Dumpster Diving: one mare's trash is another mare's treasure
Totally undisguised plot about racism.
>Alicorn Issues: find what makes you shine
More and more racism.
>Making a Foal of Me: don't spread magic glitter cum all over your friends' faces
Yet another episode about racism.

Oh god, I'm afraid you're right. Every single one of them plots is about racism.
Geepercentbros................ not like this......................
>>
>>38774017
i meant the shadow alicorn
>>
>>38774108
damn
btfo
>>
>>38774660
G5 is about racism over and over again
G5 is about the sad cyclical truth of racism
>>
>>38775341
I don't think the shadow alicorns main goal was racism
>>
>>38775745
Was or is you soulless empty chimp
>>
>>38775753
Was? She probably just used it as means to an end
also why are you so agressive bro
>>
>>38776114
It's prolly the local schizo desu
>>
>>38754698
Meh
>>
>>38754718
That's like half the board these days
>>
>>38766231
What future? The one half this board cried about for 3 years?
This board should be loving G5 solely because it shows that Haberverse resulted in collapse.
>>
>grown man asking for mlp comics>why
>>
>>38778740
what did he mean by this



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.