is he a good weapons and military analyst?
he's a drooling vatnigger shillalso>e-celebsherbed
>>58339284>is he a good weapons and military analyst?He's a blue Russian sockpuppet.
>>58339296he´s good then
>>58339284No. How can you be an analyst if your research consists of reading the issued paper stats of the platform/system, and taking them at face value?
>>58339296Either that or he takes numbers at face value much too seriously, assuming non-western and western numbers are the all equally reliable. >DURR AMERICA LIES TOOyeah but in the US it is largely not illegal to question government narratives. Our information on the structure and capabilities of the US military and its equipment is much better than our information on anything Russian or Chinese, as the current war is showing. China might be better than Russia. Or it might be even worse. We can only guess because China has no presumption of freedom of information and most of the information their military puts out publicly is just promotion.
>>58339296>sockpuppetClearly foriegn infiltrator then, I get my info from someone who knows, vasily's footwrap.
>>58339284He is "pants on head" retarded. Pre-War, he thought the same Army that can barely move more than 200KM into Ukraine, can't defeat the Ukrainian Air Force, is losing ships to a country with no Navy, and has basically run out of missiles could defeat the US. He is also incapable of differentiating between equipment quality. Basically equating a 1970's MIG to an F-35 because, "a plane is a plane", Zero credibility, zero knowledge.
>>58339284he's biased. i stopped paying attention when he called the kherson feint a "tactical retreat"
>>58339331>>58339355>official performance numbersRussia's problem isn't that their equipment is inherently garbage. Russia's problem is they don't do any maintenance, so its all in disrepair and they don't do any training so they couldn't even perform well with brand new NATO equipment.
>>58339394>He is "pants on head" retarded.nah after it became obvious invasion isnt going well he corrected himself, something many people still can't do.
>>58339435They've been flat out lying about the capabilities of their hypersonics. Which are really the only significant advancement of their capabilities since the Soviet era.
Probably less of a vatnik than Red Effect
>>58339394>differentiating between equipment qualityOh he doesHis rating scale is>mediocre>terrible>bad>poor>outdated>goodTruly a unique rating system>>58339284NoHe just takes numbers and mashes them together with no regard for training, doctrine, and readiness
>>58339454keep calm and start worshipping niggers
>go on wikipedia>look up how many soldiers an army has>base "analysis" on it, publish youtube video about some fictional conflict with no other context, just two armies fighting in a vacuum>people give you 100k usd maybe even more in donationsI feel jealous.
>>58339284>predicting Russia to own half of Ukraine by the end of winter 2022
>>58339435Their planes have good kinematics, but the radar range, sensitivity, processing ability; electronics, combat range; engine thrust; missile range, maneuverability, seeker ability, etc are all lied about, which is the most important part when going into combat. It's cool that your fighter can do aerobatics, but can it actually last in a contested airspace? It doesn't help when they're also high maintenance.
>>58339473I became trans-vatnig, so now I can. Thanks!
>>58339464A good example of how he doesn't do any research is when Russia passed a law that said every Russia who had done military service was a "Reserve". Russia then claimed to have 800,000 people in reserve and it got added to wikipedia. Actual military analysts looked into it and noticed Russia hadn't really done anything to give them proper readiness, training, or working equipment. They also only gave the "reserve" a budget of like...10 million dollars for 800,000 people. Binkov didn't go that deep, he didn't put any thought into what that meant for their combat capability. He just accepts that they have 800,000 reserves and takes it at face value for his "analysis" .
>>58339284hes a literal nigger
he's ok, but since he doesn't suck ukraine cock 24/7 keddit hates him
>>58339634you have niggers living in your city
>>58339663You have niggers living in your ass. Well, parts of them.
>>58339355Oh great, we can say I hate the government to an audience of 2. Better not gain any actual power that has any chance of causing change though! You'll get prison or disappeared just like Russia. But I can say "I hate the govt" because we don't have a strongman culture. Believe me, the Russian govt wouldn't waste resources on stopping that kind of stuff if Russian citizens wouldn't perceive it as weak and oust Putin. Its part of a shame based culture whereas we have a guilt based culture.At least they aren't in any danger of becoming woke and hating themselves tho, that's an upside.
>>58339547>Implying that compares to Americas level of nigger worship and wasn't just a pr stunt to sway westerners playing off of their very nigger worshipI mean you know it is, you won't admit it, but deep down you do. Extremely dumb people don't really care about weapons enough to go on an image board.
>>58339854Russia has loved niggers for decades. Even Jewtin himself said Russia is a multicultural society, has been one from the start, and will continue to do so as it's the strength of Russia. Stop coping and projecting.
>>58339673I suppose I'm him too? Or do you have some other dude to ascribe to me?I wish the Russian side were better about doxxing people. I've seen some funny shit from you guys like switching from the "le based nahtzee Ukrainian" to posting bbc demoralization because he forgot which thread he was in, then deleted it when called out, but I don't have cubicles of employees so it's hard to investigate all this crap to keep up with the glowies
>>58339284Clearly a tuber who swallowed the Russia STRONK pill ages ago. With the reality hitting most vatnik's face at full speed, Binkov's latest videos have been more realistic. Which has cause a considerable amount of seething among his fans in the comments, who accuse him of being a NAFO shill now.O tempora, o mores!
>>58339891Russia is LITERALLY a multicultural society, you're framing this disingenuously. They conquered Asia all the way to the Pacific. I guess you expect them to just genocide all the people living there?
>>58339902WOW A BLACK RUSSIAN, THERES NO BLACK UKRAINIANS OR WESTERNERS HOLY SHIT YOU CONVERTED ME.bruh there were black people in Nazi germanyHowever they're kept in line in Russia and no one is kissing their boots or letting them riot and there's hardly any. Most have never seen one
>>58339284His analysis basically consists of taking the claimed stats and numbers of weapons and men, and then figuring out what happens based on thatIn situations where the figures he uses are accurate, his analysis is accurate. In situations where the figures used are inaccurate, his analysis is inaccurateIf you want to see a really good example of this, go back and watch his pre war video on whether Russia could take UkraineAll the stuff he predicted based on western/Ukrainian figures happened, and all the stuff he predicted based on Russian figures did not
>>58339952Bro you are literally just saying its different when Russia does itIt's not different when Russia does it, the Russian propaganda regarding multiculturalism and nigger worship is blatantly hypocritical, just like everything else they hold up as en example of alleged Russian superiority over the west
>>58339284cute puppet, often wrong but that's partially due to him taking more risks and writing about hypothetical scenarios.
>>58339782You're barely legible. The reason why anti government retards do not possess significant power at the governmental is three fold>There aren't very many of them>They're retards>They're anti governmentYou think anti government retards are going to seek office? It's self exclusion, dipshit
>>58339939>I guess you expect them to just genocide all the people living there?Yes. Why not?>>58339952The cope is STRONG. I can see you're, also, seething quite badly. Maybe it's time to close the thread, if that doesn't work, turn your computer off and go for a walk. The sun and fresh air will do you good, and give you time to calm down. Being this mad isn't good for your cardiovascular system. Overexposure of adrenaline, and cortisol can seriously damage your body and mind.
Only miltuber I like is Perun.
>>58339473Given the choice between niggers and snowniggers, the OG is preferable.
>>58339605So many of his videos have examples like those. Which is why he almost always claims non-NATO countries would successfuly invade NATO ones or force concessions if war broke between the two. Look at any of his northern africa vs southern europe videos, it becomes utterly hilarious. Every time he claims the NAFRAs would somehow beat the EU, every single time. And most times he claims war of attrition is why they would. As if the EU's absolutely massive industrial output wouldn't trump the shit out of the african reserves in such a scenario. Simply hilarious.
gulaghomo is just as multi-ethnic as globohomo, just different parts of the world with different ideologies.
I'm a task&purpose guy myself
>>58339547>>58339902>>58340002>>58340017Good job everypony. Now we have proven the vatnik's vranyo is as bullshit as everything else that comes out of their stinking country, lets get back on track and keep shitting on the blue sockpuppet.Anyone got any other examples of him being shit?
>>58340420>everyponyYou did this, accept the consequences.
> is this youtuber a good weapons and military analystnone of them are
>>58339394Which video are you referring to? He made one saying the US could successfully invade Russia if there were no nukes.https://youtu.be/ZleHYi59n7Q
>>58339284No. Routinely gets information wrong that you can find just by going to wikipedia of all places.One of his videos about the russian navy said that the USN's submarines didn't have any cruise missiles which is just fucking crazy to say.
>>58339915Oh tempura, oh more!
>>58339284He is not very crescent fresh
You can tell which youtubers are good or not based on how the vatniks react to them. If they spam every criticism with screeching about trannies then they’re not good. If they sperg out at the mere mention of them then they’re good
>>58340267I like Covert Cabal because he buys satellite photos and counts tank depots and airfield equipment. Perun is great for procurement videos but his analysis of the current conflict is milquetoast.
>>58339284Not really. His content just boils down to "looks at numbers and country with bigger number wins".
>>58339689You have niggers living in your mind. Rent free!
>>58340002of course it is different! For one thing, the history of blacks in Russia differs greatly from the history of blacks in the USA.
>>58339296>sockpuppet>sockclearly HATO technology
>>58340339>northern africa vs southern europe This retard seriously argues in favor of like Libya being victorious in a war against Europe? Is this retard high lmao, Europe could fucking demolish the northern African seaboard without dropping a single soldier on enemy soil.
>>58339782>WeIts blatantly obvious you're not american, shill
>>58340339His F-35 vs Su-35 video is retarded like this. Basically since we "can't know" the stealth parameters exactly, he just abandons the whole idea, ignores datalinks and everything else to just come up with a stupid scenario where the F-35 barely wins.I can't believe the faggot used to post on here. Good on him if he got popular though.
>>58339284He has been wrong on just about everything pertaining to the Ukraine war.
>>58342295>I can't believe the faggot used to post on here.how do you know?
>>58339473pidors get the rope
>>58339473Fuck off, commietroon
>>58342356poland pipo looks like THAT?????
>>58342317Because he posted one of his first videos to ask for advice a few years back.
>>58339296The people who make Binkov's Battlegrounds are Croats, it's not all one guy though of course the voice is.
>>58339284>a literal sockpuppetthe absolute state of /k/
>>58343817Also none of them are black that I know of
>>58343817then who is binkov?
>>58343848The puppet is named Binkov, there is no actual Binkov unless you consider the guy who does the voice but he doesn't write all the shit he says so is he Binkov? I don't think so.
>>58339966I think the best takeaways from his takes is pointing out how important terrain features and distance are. Many of the lopsided matchups that require force projection often end upwith "it won't be an immediate victory and the invader will need to mobilize and enter a war economy", which really underscores how much of a deterrent defending forces can be, and how costly it is to do logistics even within your region. It's also pretty clever to use time travel scenarios to showcase logistics sustainment concerns like running out of shells and missiles.That's basically the one note the bluegreen sockpuppet can play, and many videos are just rehashes of old ones but with different flags and Wikipedia numbers. He really needs more content as in the-core-point-of-the-video. Like maybe compare how an operation would go with good weather versus bad weather, I dunno.
>>58339317What you don't know is that that puppet is not just blue, it's not turquoise, it's not lapis... It's actually cerulean.
>>58339284All his analyses come down to "muh numbers", "muh numbers, blyat". They're worth shit.
>>58339284know nothing. like most faggots who talk through a puppet he is incapable of quantifying the advantages of individual pieces of equipment. seldom does he know what is important but regardless he compares any compararbles that may be found.it produces meaningless advantages and is so dependent on treating all available information as equal despite that it is comparing sales brochures to admitted capabilities
>>58339284He knows he'd lose a lot of viewers if he's too pro-Russia, but in fairness, the US always wins in every single one of his hypothetical scenarios
>>58339284General Grunt’s weird cousin
>>58347506Didn’t expect him to get mentioned but here the fuck we are I guess
>>58339782Barry from New York Oblast here, this man is spitting facts no cap fr fr.
>>58339284>this side has more tanks than the other side>therefore this side will win in a warEvery binkov video everCaptcha:xdrgay
>>58347773He never once considers the manufacturing and logistic capabilities of any country in question>here numbers from biased sourced>here capabilities from biased source>ignore more complicated intricacies >this likely outcomeHe's not terrible, he's covering an incredibly complicated subject so the margin for error is expected to be off the charts.
>>58339394WRONG.EVERYONE - yes that includes YOU - predicted that Russia would steamroll Ukraine. His predictions were the most bearish for Russia relative to everyone else. Ergo he was the most correct.
>>58339284WORDCELS are mad that he applies quantitative analysis. He's actually watchable compared to werdios like Perun that just go on 3 hour autistic rants with ZERO reference to any real world data.
>>58342317he started this thread
>>58339854someone post the synopsis of stalin's favourite movie for this faggot
>>58339513lol I remember that and how Ukraine was helpless even with Western aid.
>>58339394Wut? The videos I've watched he clearly differentiates the aircraft by quality - eg F-35 "excellent" down to 1950s relics "terrible" etc.
>>58344002I think one annoying thing he pulls is he assumes that the nation with the better economy will just automatically win.Like when he had 1939 Germany invade Poland who's army had been replaced by the 2020 Polish army.He still says Germany Wins.... because economy and manpower. He fails to take into account that the Polish Airforce could simply launch decapitating strikes on both Berlin and Moscow.With Hitler and Stalin both dead the two nations would have so much infighting the war might never even happen.
>>58347957I actually didn't and I have logs with my friends to prove it. Predicted that Russia would be halted at the big border cities because there is no way they can take big cities that resist anymore. Defense is king again. I will forever be smug about this prediction.
>>58339293>>58339296>He took official given numbers at face value instead of going off nothing at all>That makes him a ziggerI dream every day of breaking the hands of War tourists so they can no longer come here
>>58339284>predicted rapid & victorious vatnik blitzkriegThat hurt his credibility somewhat.Still kinda enjoy watching some of his videos for some reason (I've learned to condition my mind in such a way as to simply milk the subliminal for loosh without getting psyopped or propagandized).
>>58339284Cucknkov's Battlegrounds has always been a cringe Russiaboo tankie, as if the name wasn't a dead giveaway.
Anyone who would have predicted the reality of the russian retardation pre-war would be laughed out the room, you couldn't sabotage a war effort more effectively than they've managed to do.
>>58352782I have a friend who comes from a large soldiering family, with contacts all over from Space to the Marines. She predicted a shitshow on Day 1 of the invasion, and I didn't believe her then.
>>58339891During the earlier decades of the Soviet Union, and even into the Cold War a bit, it wasn't uncommon for the black Americans and other assorted niggers from across the world to go study at Moscow State University. There's a not-small amount of writings by famous leftwing niggers effusively praising the egalitarian society that was in the USSR lmao.When is /pol/ going to fucking learn that Russia is the unironic, literal progenitor of le globohomo?
>>58348662>He still says Germany Wins.... because economy and manpoweryeah lol noit's clear he has zero idea of WW2 production rates, and zero idea of how WW2 combat differed from combat today. Not to mention that you can't rely on that factory cranking out thousands of Stug IIIs when Polish T-72s are at the gates of Berlin within a month
>>58350718>He took official given numbers at face value instead of going off nothing at all >That makes him a zigger Yes.
>>58347957Nope, I saw that Russia had only put around 200K soldiers around Ukraine and that was their entire army and I LOL'd about how badly it would go trying to take everything all at once. If I was willing to doxx myself I'd post my social media to prove it. Russia has always been dogshit militarily.
>>58348235>how Ukraine was helpless even with Western aid.they are, still are, hence the "offensive" in belgorod to distract attention from Bakhmut (MOOT MOOT)
>>58339284He was already discredited before Ukraine, he predicted Armenia/Azerbaijan would be a decade long stalemate that would end with Armenia keeping almost all of its occupied territory.
>>58354257Not on the timescale that Binkov gave and that is the one I am judging him on.
>>58339284He is the FPS Russia of miltubers. I can’t believe he called the F-15EX “Puresex” lmao
>>58339284Hes a vatnik still who put the Ukraine offensive as a tactical retreat by the Russians. The same shit Russian state propaganda was spewing. "We didnt get kicked out of our position, we merely left"
>>58358965He's not even an actual vatnik, just a western leftypol contrarian tankie like Comrade Cucktko.
>>58339284I think he tries to be fair and give his perspective. I personally think his VA/writer is a Russian living in Russia. I think most of the impartiality coems from the fact the writer/VA is aware of his own position in parody commentary and does what he does because he expects everyone to just accept that he is 100% wrong and it doesn't matter. so if he does say something that isn't state approved he can just slide by, by saying "western propaganda" or "this character is a sock puppet and is playing part on a parody."I mean if you apply russian logic:>Russia says their equipment is full functional and has a good ratio>binkov only talks about the Russian position as if this was true regardless of the proof of hides the truth with a heavy dose of salt.so ultimately he operates with a Russian bias based on the best possible realistic outcome for Russia. therefore he isn't disloyal to russia and can continue to operate. he also appears to avoid talking about issues that are currently called into question with Ukraine and does some talking.
>>58339293>>58339296>>58339331>>58339355>>58339394>>58339447>>58339450>>58339513>>58339645>>58339915reminder this is his prediction from Jan 26, 2022:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9c_HhpvBpg He was more correct than 90% of /k/ who said Ukraine will fall within several days. He nailed effect of sanctions too. Vatniggers hate and discredit him for same reason as Perun. It is because he speaks truth and truth makes vatniggers mad.
>>58360267lmao even Binkov is better than P*run, at least he puts some production on his videos. Yes, the puppets are cuh-riiiiiiiiinge but it's SOMETHING, unlike P*run who just straight up reads wikipedia while a powerpoint with images from GIS plays in the background.
>>58360267Also I welcome any better blog/video that was more accurate than Binkov's
>let's strip the countries of everything and do a 1vs1 on a ring where only quantity and an extremely simplified quality scale matter Of course it's doomed to be atrociously bad and incorrect. It's barely a step above globalfirepower rankings.
>>58339284Trusting a retarded muppet
>>58360287>P*run who just straight up reads wikipediayou fucking WISH wikipedia was that good
>>58339284He's decent from what I've seen. He pretty accurately said the Russian military is a complete mess and would struggle a lot with invading Ukraine well before the invasion happened. Accurately called out how incompetent the officers and training were. I don't know where him taking everything at face value as people in this thread are saying came from, maybe in some of his older videos, but I haven't watched everything from him only a couple vids.
>>58348662Hell the Polish BMP-1s would have been more than a match for a Panzer II.
I don't know why everyone is saying he's a Russian shill. He's hardly anything but. He overestimated the Russians in the past but so did everyone.
>>58360287>lmao even Binkov is better than P*runThis is pure, bitter seethe and/or raw contrarianism and nothing more. You're saying objectively retarded shit here, anon.
>>58362980/k/ is glownigger central so he isn´t official narrative approved by the US government and that makes him a "russian shill" somehowthe fact that ukraine is losing the war, makes everyone here mad insane
>>58362980Most of /k/ overestimated Russia, it's just that they don't have their name permanently attached to those opinions.
>>58339284Haven't literally all of this dude's war predictions been completely wrong?
Reminder that Binkov is not one guy, it's a team of Croatians and there is no "him" or "that guy" unless you're referring to the actual hand puppet which is named Binkov
>>58366169Not at all
>>58366253The puppet is alive and making all of the videos itself