What went right?What went wrong?
>>39978641>What went right?Half of them>What went wrong?The other half
>>39978641The Sinnoh dex is so goddamn awful, holy shit.
i made one with a white background in case you wanted to edit the pic with paint
All of them went right except for Rhyperior and Magmortar.
>>39978641Mismagius, Porygon Z, Honchkrow, Gliscor, Leafeon and Glaceon went right.Weaville, Tangrowth, Magnezone and Yanmega, Gallade, Mammoswine and Froslass went somewhere.Probopass, Ambipom, Magmortar, Electivire, Roserade, Lickilicky, Dusknoir, Togekiss and Rhyperior went wrong.
Sinnohfags usually are insecure and just attack anyone here with their own based opinions even if the other anons are being chill, so whatever, here is my own taste.I personally like very much some of these Pokémon, but from all the main 5 gens, Gen 4 is the one I few less connection. The region look nice, yes, but I don't like of the majority of the Pokémon design.
>>39978641Gliscor, Gallade Mamozwine,PoryZ,Yanmega,Wealive, Evee's, Roserade and Togekiss went right.The rest are just forgettable that are evolution of the forgotten
>>39978737those trash tier bugs above darkrai? LMAO
>>39978641Wrong: Magmortar, RhyperiorRight: Everything elseI don't like Probopass, but I also don't like Nosepass, and the two fit with each other just fine and have their fans. I don't know if I've ever seen a Magmortar fan.Roserade is an absolute bro, I run one in Platinum and I'm training up a Roselia in X.
>>39978641While I would change some typings and think a handful need a redesign either slightly(gallade's hips and magmortar's lips) to the full on redesigns like rhyperior. I feel like they make up a little too much of the sinnoh dex maybe if there was 15-25 new normal mons I wouldn't feel this way
>rightyanmega, mismagius, porygon-z, honchkrow, dusknoir, gallade, eevee pair>wrongthe rest
>>39978737>Darkrai in C tierList can be safely disregarded, nothing of value.
>>39978641i like electivire and yanmegamagnezone is kind of cool but i like magneton more same for dusknoir and mamoswine the rest are bad
op posting taste
>>39978641PerfectYanmega, Mismagius, Porygon Z, Honchkrow, Gallade, Mamoswine, Gliscor, Froslass, Magnezone (i hated 10 years ago but now i like him), Roserade (and also Budew), Weavile (same as Magnezone), Dusknoir, Glaceon, Leafeon (hated only the choice of the evolution method because now exists ice and leaf stone)OkElectivire, Lickylicky (only because i don't know what they can choose after Lickytung)To redesignMagmortar (hate the body but not the concept), Rhyperior (Rhydon is cooler, but the concept is cool)Why?Probopass (WTF), Tangrowth (A big Tangela), Togekiss (I never understood what is that or what was the concept)
>>39978641>What went right?Yanmega, Honchcrow, Gallade, Misdreavus, Gliscor, Electivire, Froslass, Magnezone, Roserade, Weavile, Togekiss, Dusknoir, Glaceon, Porygon Z, Probopass, Tangrowth>What went wrong?Ambipom, Mamoswine, Rypherior, LickyLicky
i love them all
>>39978641>God tierMismagius>Great tierYanmega, Leafeon>Good tierRoserade, Weavile, Porygon-Z, Froslass>Average tierGallade, Glaceon, Gliscor, Honchkrow, Probopass, Togekiss>Poor tierMagnezone, Electivire, Ambipom, Mamoswine, Tangrowth>Irredeemable garbage tierMagmortar, Rhyperior, Dusknoir, Lickilicky
>>39978852I forget in the Why? Ambipom
>What went right?All of them>What went wrong?None of them
>>39978802>>39978839Yes. I don't like how that thing look like. But I guess you have your nostalgic glasses to see that and love.
four categoriesa good evolution in order of worth>froslass>probopass>yanmega>mamoswine>honchkrow>mismagiussuperior to original but a bad evolution>gliscor >lickilicky>rotomz>glaceon>electivire>magnezoneok -- feels like a mega evolution>rhyperior>ambipom>tangrowtha bad/uninteresting evolution>gallade>togekiss>magmortar>weavile>dusknoir>leafeon
>>39978657This, it was another Johto ass extension.At least Kanto, Hoenn and Unova introduced a sizable dex on it's own
>>39978657Your taste is so goddamn awful, holy shit.
>>39978981hoenn and unova were both soft reboots
>>39978641I just hate Ambipom and Lickylicky
>>39978641Only Rhyperior, Magmortor, and Lickilicky are shit in design
>>39979018can you post the link for that template?
>>39978641The only bad designs on there are Ambipom and Lililicky.
>>39978988this is why they were good imo
Considering most of them are positive-neutral, the Gen 4 cross-gen evos were pretty good.
they made a bunch pokemon useful?! fuck, why would they do this?
>>39979018what's wrong with yanmega? what does cohesive mean in this context?
>>39978641I feel like the only real stinkers are Lickilicki, Magmortar, Ambipom, and maybe Rhyperior. Everything else is pretty good.
>>39979098Yanmega fuckin ugly m8.
>>39979104dragonflies aren't supposed to be pretty.
>>39979101accurate, those are the only debatable ones
mamoswine is flawless, and that's a fact
Green I like, Yellow could have been better, Red I hate, and the others are kind of meh but I don't think they are bad
>>39978641Honestly, none of them are perfect to me, but I suppose the goofiness is intentional and it just doesn't click with me. But I only really dislike Honchcrow, Tangrowth, Lickilicky, Rhyperior and Dusknoir for spoiling their evolution lines, and even though Magenzone, Weavile, Glaceon and Togekiss aren't as bad, they're still not as cool as they should be.
Best one of the bunch.
>>39978641I like a majority of them but their shinies are ass. Just blue or red instead of whatever. Look at magnezone and magneton, ruined.
>>39979104but how is it not cohesive? I would say it has a pretty legible geometric language, which is refined to mostly banding elliptical shapes of only three colours. I don't really like itmyself but I wouldn't call it incoherent
>>39978641only one I don't particularly like is Rhyperior. Should have just went full kaiju
>>39978641here OP I crossed out the garbage
>>39978641>>39978641I feel like all these pokemon (minus Mamo and Spagzilla) are underrated in competitive. Especially Mismag and RoseradeDesign wise the only ones I'm not a fan of are Magmortar and the Jewish one
>>39978641>Godsend:Weavile, Gliscor, Gallade, Mismagius, Ambipom>What went right:Porygon-Z, Honchkrow, Tangela, Magnezone, Roserade, Dusknoir>Bugshit:Yanmega>Disgrace to the franchise and it's own line:Electivire, Magmortar, Probopass, Rhyperior>What went wrong:Togekiss, Froslass, Lickilicky, Mamoswine, Leafeon, Glaceon
They could have been better but they are overall good.
>>39978641They only ones that are wrong are Rhyperior and Magmortar.The rest are varying degrees of okay to great.
>>39978663This but add Lickilicky
>>39978737Absolute excrement taste list.
>>39978641>Based:Gliscor, Yanmega, Honchkrow, Roserade, Weavile, Mamoswine, Mismagius, Leafeon, Glaceon, Magnezone, PZ, Gallade, Froslass, Electivire, Togekiss, Dusknoir>MehLickilicky, Magmortar, Probopass, Tangrowth>CringeRhyperior, AmbipomOverall they did pretty good
>>39978641In no particular order>what went rightPorygon-ZGalladeMamoswineGliscorTangrowthFroslassMismagiusMagnezoneRoseradeGlaceonDusknoir>what went okHonchkrowAmbipomLeafeonLickilickyTogekissYanmegaProbopass>what went wrongRhyperiorElectivireMagmortarWeavile
>>39980338I think a good question to ask is: if the evolution was released in the same game as the base pokemon would you be confused by a lack of change or an incongruous change. Consider the evolutions of pokemon that were already pretty developed or "adult", so>electivire>rhyperior>magortar>togekiss>dusknoirwhich feel unnecessary. Then consider the evolutions that are excessive; these override the clarity or perfection of the base form>honchkrow>probopass>roserade>mismagius>weavile especially>ambipom more especially>gallade in terms of the line as a wholethen there are pokemon that are arguably better executions of the original idea but which feel either excessive or unnecessary>gliscor>porygonz>lickilicky >tangrowthyou are left with three pokemon that respect the vibe of the base form and physically impress of meaningful change>yanmega>mamoswine>froslassthe eevees aren't really relevant to this discussion, but I'll say they're pretty boring. I like vaporeon and sylveon.
>>39978649Agreed, about half of em went right. I feel like they didnt need to make 22 new evos. They couldve started with 10 at most
>>39978985If Sinnoh is your favourite dex, then yours really is. It's objectively the worst dex.
What went wrong is not allowing most of these cross gen evos until the post-game and making the regional dex extremely limited
>good tierCan evolve with an item or move on level up.>bad tierhave to trade to evolve
>>39978657Don't forget about the 7 (seven) completely pointless baby pokemon added in Gen4! Munchlax, Happiny, Mime Jr., Bonsly, Mantyke, Chingling, and Budew! All with horrible methods of birth and/or evolution to artificially extend the time needed to obtain all of them!
I like cross-gen evos a lot and wish they did them more. I wish these ones were more viable in general thoI also love Probopass and don't get why people hate it so much. I think it's a very nice progression from Nosepass and I really want to use one. I mean, I wish the typing was better, but
>>39978641this is all my opinion, but here i go with my rant of some of the ones I wish were different>YanmegaCool that yanma got an evo, but it lost all it's charm and gained little: great speed boost user, given its high special attack, but still as frail as a real dragonfly, and STILL a bug/flying in the gen that introduced sneaky pebblesHow I would have liked it:>10 more points in Sp.Def>Bug/Dragon>Levitate instead of Frisk (gives more options for builds)>MismagiusOnly received 60 BPS boost through evo, which did not fix the issues with Misdreavus. What I feel should have been done>+20 HP>the magic aspect should have been expanded and it should have been GHOST/PSYCHIC>ProbopassReminds me of the Onyx/Steelix issue.>-20 Sp.Def>+20 HPFighting and Ground are mainly physical attackers, HP is more useful in a pokemon such as it (surely, 60 HP even with really high defenses cant be good)Oh yes also the design is SHIT. >lol its jew rockYeah, Its shit.>Magmortar and Electrivire>+10 HP, +10 Defjust a very very mediocre change but it lets it be a tiny bit more bulkyas opposed to many, i love their designs, but they LOOK bulky, so why arent they? >FroslassFAST-ish FRAIL MIXED ATTACKERAlong with Glalie it should have been buffed.>Give it Levitate>-10 Attack>+10 Sp.Attack>+10 Speed (which Glalie should have gotten too)It's not great but it can be a sweeper of sort, and have a free switch on Ground types>LickilickyThis pokemon has to reason to exist, especially with such lame design. Its tongue is smaller than Lickytung's and so is its dick.>better design, more enfasis on the tongue rather than being fat>+10 Attack so it can do...somethingThe rest are fine in my book. I didnt overdo on buffs, just minor adjustments,
>>39978737>Mandrill face and 2 downgrades in S tierStopped there
>>39978658aw thanks anon, how throughtful
>>39978641Everyone in this thread that says evolutions/pre-evolutions are unnecessary is wrong. There's literally no better way to introduce new Pokemon than to tie them to older Pokemon, especially when it comes to the excitement of finding out that there is a new baby Pokemon or a new final evolution.Granted, some of the designs suck and could definitely have been improved or remade from scratch, like Lickilicky, Rhyperior or Magmortar, but that doesn't mean that Lickitung, Rhydon or Magmar shouldn't have had evolutions.Stop thinking that Pokemon is only for competitive battling. Many people appreciate the franchise for the worldbuilding and coherence they managed to have up until Gen IV and don't give a fuck about muh viable Pokemon. I would prefer 100 new evolutions or pre-evolutions added to pre-Gen V Pokemon than the absolute shit we got afterwards, which was made even worse by the fact that except for Sylveon there was no link to the first four generations or between the new generation themselves.
>>39981279>having such a shit opinionyikesbaby pokemon are never pointless you smogon addict, get over yourself, this is not a battling simulator
I guess the objective answer is not great, not terrible, but I still don't like it because some of these are utter hoseshit.
>>39982208This also Gen V was the only meta where the same shitty gimmick plagued every tier.
>>39978737Sell me on Bronzong, I've tried to like it since it has a cool design origin and a damn good typing but it's just so boring and unappealing.
>>39978641Too much “gets fat”. And penis finger monkey ruined Aipom. I can no longer like Aipom
Thanks for giving Rhydon, the first Pokémon ever created, a really terrible evolution that sour Rhydon itself by proxy.
some are a bit edgy but it's a part of gen 4's charmat least they bothered giving older pokemon attention
Am I too easy to impress? Dunno, I just like most of them and I think they're perfectly fine evolution designs.
>>39978972>RotomzU wat niibba?
>>39979104Yanmega looks sick. What are you on?
Pokemon's 2nd most potent pleb filer, outdone only by Vanilluxe.
>>39978641Nothing. The only one I don't like is Probopass and Mamoswine. The availability of them however...is a problem. Its like they don't exist outside of Platnium and half of them don't learn good move's or you can have better pokemon of the same type on your team.
>>39981279baby pokemon serve a valuable purpose in the games of allowing earlier access to powerful pokemon, as a result increasing early-game diversity
When will the rhyperior hate meme end?
>>39978641>What went right?Mamoswine, Gliscor, Porygon-Z and Magnezone>What went wrong?the rest
>>39978737>Staraptor>DThis actually hurt my feelings. Die
>>39986315Rhydonfags will eternally seethe about based RhySuperior
>>39978737>Floatzel, Staraptor, Pachirisu, Palkia, Porygon-Z>D>Rhyperior>lowest tierend yourself, this is beyond shit taste
>>39978641They are pretty good, but I'm mad they butchered my boy magmarMagmortar is probably the ugliest Pokemon
What y’all think?
>>39986390Based and the best post itt
>>39981674>Bug/DragonNoIt’s best ability is Tinted Lens anyways so you’re better off boosting its speed
>>39985879>>39985895You’re forgetting someone
>>39979104CEO of shit taste has logged on
>>39985589What did you want? A bigger Rhydon with more spikes?>itjustgetsbigger