[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Search] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/mu/ - Music


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.



File: LAST5.png (66 KB, 596x361)
66 KB
66 KB PNG
Post Em'

I was probably being a bit generous on these ratings.
>>
File: ksjbkjbfk.png (120 KB, 1318x495)
120 KB
120 KB PNG
>>87172062
>>
File: 900.png (98 KB, 683x457)
98 KB
98 KB PNG
>>87172062
happy 900 /moo/
>>
>>87172478
Marquee Moon is pretty good, I've never listened to anything else by them though

>>87172511
cheers anon
>>
>>87172062
I’ve only listened to Thaiboy Goon before but wouldn’t rate anything by him that high

>>87172478
Marquee Moon is alright but not 5 stars kind of alright

>>87172511
>>87172533
Never listened to anything from your recent ratings
>>
>>87172511
Only ones I’ve heard is road to ruin and pacific daydream, and your ratings are accurate expect maybe slightly generous on rtr

>>87172478
I’m with that other guy I like marquee moon but 10/10?
>>
>>87172582
>I’ve only listened to Thaiboy Goon before but wouldn’t rate anything by him that high
I was surprised. Really wasn't expecting to think that much of it. I enjoy some of Drain Gangs work like certain releases of Bladee and Yung Lean. But Thaiboy Digital and that mixtape seems vastly underrated, it's better than Eversince in my honest opinion.
>>
>>87172062
pretty high for endless, how would you compare to his other work?
>>
File: Untitled.png (64 KB, 1416x346)
64 KB
64 KB PNG
ayo
>>
>>87172650
Oh, it's been forever since heard that XTC album

>>87172582
Yeah, The Pop Group hardly deversves something higher than what you gave em

>>87172533
Empath is good, don't be mean

>>87172511
Have 0 interest in High on Fire, same shit over and over

>>87172478
The debut is a good record, I won't despute that, guitar playing is amazing, and I think I'm gradually warming up to the vocals

>>87172062
I see the potential grower in Endless, but I doubt it'd be to a 4.5
>>
File: rrrrr.png (62 KB, 609x336)
62 KB
62 KB PNG
>>87172582
I ADMIT MY CRIME
IM A THIEF OF FIRE
>>87172788
Going Blank Again is better than Nowhere, isn't it?
>>87172888
based Texas-Jerusalem
>>
>>87172062
Probably
>>87172582
Y is at least an 8
>>87172888
That Takashi rating a little too generous imo
>>
>>87173024
excellent, violent femmes is one of my favourites.
>>
>>87172976
I haven't given Nowhere a full listen yet but I might as I found Going Blank pretty great
>>
>>87172788
>pretty high for endless, how would you compare to his other work?
I loved it. Big fan of Frank Ocean though, Not a single bad release. Endless is easily his second best, beaten by Blond only slightly.
>>87173024
Based. Another Triad God listener.
>>87172788
God damn. Another Titanic Rising rating and post. Is it really that good?
>>
>>87173267
>Titanic Rising
I think its a bit overrated but the highlights on it are great (Movies, Everyday, Andromeda) meanwhile there are some boring tracks (Wild Time, Mirror Forever). Production is great throughout. I respect that endless rating although I think its worse than both Blonde and CO.
>>
>>87172898
>Have 0 interest in High on Fire, same shit over and over
I'm not one to use the tourist meme, but how on earth do you think that genuinely, if you do. Luminiferous sounds markedly stylistically different from De vermis mysteriis, which sounds markedly different from Snakes for the Divine, which sounds markedly different from Surrounded by Thieves. Each album I just listed focuses on something different musically each time.
>>
I literally haven't listened to anything in thread
>>
>>87173569
Not surprising, looks like you're a /reddit/core normal faggot.
>>
>>87173589
Heck yeah car seat headrest is my jam bro!
>>
>>87172650
you need to relisten to Wowee Zowee a few more times
>>
>>87173562
Perhaps I'm wrong, and I just lost interest in the band. Of course, they weren't totally putting out the same album from the start, there was quite a bit of evolution up until 2010, so maybe I just moved on from them and every time I tried something since it generally didn't sound that much different to me. You know how that happens. I'm sure there're some details, but don't make it sound like there were some Boris/Ulver-like huge shifts in sound and style
>>
File: Capturar.png (71 KB, 709x329)
71 KB
71 KB PNG
>>87172533
bonkuu~
>>
File: uh.png (119 KB, 1538x551)
119 KB
119 KB PNG
>>87172062
gave same score to triad god but considering bumping him
>>87172478
television
>>87172511
900 and taste still shit *sigh*
>>87172533
did you just rate a fucking single
>>87172582
accurate
>>87172976
ay fuck arzachel
>>87173024
triad god good
>>87173569
congratulations retard
>>87173917
made me check albergo intergalattico spaziale
>>
File: nin.png (67 KB, 901x319)
67 KB
67 KB PNG
Gonna get slaughtered for the middle one
>>
>>87173870
>don't make it sound like there were some Boris/Ulver-like huge shifts in sound and style
I didn't. But when the albums are clearly focusing on majorly different aspects of the genre (for example, De vermis mysteriis' focus was on being as loud and aggressive as possible, whereas the focus on luminiferous was making a smoother, much more melodic record), it's extremely silly to imply they're making the same record over and over.
>>
>>87174217
Idler Wheel is too low but I do think it’s overrated
>>87173569
Did you start listening to music today? Newfound Interest is a great emo band tho
>>87173024
I remember you from last thread, VF ratings are still hella based.
>>
>>87172976
why only 3* for Miami? I fucking love that album(and band). Texas Serenade is insane
>>87172650
Lifestylez should be a 5 but I guess I can handle that
>>87172533
Are you generally a Townsend fan? I'm thinking about touring his discog soon
>>87172582
Y is a 5 big dog. Give it more listens
>>
>>87174260
oof ya that's pretty bad but your Pharoah and Hop Along rates are on point and Knife is just slightly too low
>>
File: ratings.png (218 KB, 1487x596)
218 KB
218 KB PNG
my rating system is extremely positive

>>87172582
check out ludus if you haven't already
>>87173917
have you heard anything else from The Thing? I personally thought their last album was fantastic
>>87174260
karma is a 5 you fool
>>
>>87172062
>>
>>87176143
>have you heard anything else from The Thing?
no, I'm not usually a free jazz guy
I will check out their last, thanks buddybro
>>
>>87176143
Like what I've heard from Art Ensemble so far but I definitely need to dive deeper into them.
>>87176716
correct Weyes score. Contrarians need not apply. Unnatural world is pretty good but probably a 3 for me. Deathconsciousness is a 4.5 of course. And I think Ten is a great album, what's your problem with it?
>>
>>
File: Screenshot_111.jpg (129 KB, 512x392)
129 KB
129 KB JPG
>>87172650
nice choices. love clouddead and xtc but i need to hear Big L

>>87172888
i'm a big fan of lift to experience and that particular Unwound album ... took me a long time to come around to it

>>87173569
don't worry you'll gain experience as time passes on although i'd try listening to stuff that ISN'T so popular, what're your favorite genres?

>>87175118
the byrds are under appreciated
>>
>>87176798
Yeah Titanic Rising is the shit, gonna try and see Weyes next month in DC if I’m able. Deathcon is one of my 9 fives too. I’ve always hated Eddie Vedder’s vocals but I do see why people enjoy it.
>>
File: New Canvas.jpg (325 KB, 753x792)
325 KB
325 KB JPG
>>87172788
>>87172888
>>87172976
>>87176883
based
>>
>>87176883
>Everybody Digs Bill Evans

facts

>>87172888
Correct Unwound score, even if it's not their best album
>>87176886
I'm hoping to catch her too, in Nashville. Everyday and Wild Times are my favorite tracks. I can definitely get that. Black in particular tho is one of the greatest songs to make pop radio in the 90's
>>87176883
Agree with all of these(I gave Hum a 4.5 but yea, it's great)

>Byrds

I've loved them for a long time, just hadn't rated em. Now I'm doing the 1001 albums to listen to before I die so I'm returning to em. Fifth Dimension is their best imo
>>87177086
I hate Orange Juice
>sorry
>>
>>87177184
orange juice reminds me scammers, one of my favorite artists so i liked it quite a bit.
>>
>>87177295
Hm, Never heard of Scammers
>>
>>87172062
Endless isn’t that good
>>87172478
Based
>>87172511
Ramones fucking suck
>>
File: wp_ss_20190416_0002.png (478 KB, 720x1280)
478 KB
478 KB PNG
>>
>>87173569

Replying to
>>87176883
>>87175118
>>87173589

The thing is i listen to a fuck tom of music, i just hardly use rym and so far ive only been rating the automatic recs
>>
>>87178031
Oh okay I gotcha. Just rate everything you’ve listened to enough times that you can formulate one from memory and go from there
>>
>>
>>87178877
based retard
>>
File: Capture.png (60 KB, 573x317)
60 KB
60 KB PNG
>>87172062
>>
>>87178877
I might be even more offended by the 3.5 for shitty Kauai than the .5 for TMR
>>87178973
Agreed on Singing Saw, and respect the Ulver rate. Great band. Can’t get into BSS though. I find them quite uninteresting
>>
Bump
>>
>>
God tier thread
>>
File: afafsafra.png (349 KB, 914x958)
349 KB
349 KB PNG
>>
File: IMG_20190416_165746.jpg (245 KB, 1080x1145)
245 KB
245 KB JPG
I was actually unprepared for how bad ? was gonna be
>>
File: rym.png (65 KB, 902x343)
65 KB
65 KB PNG
>>87180897
and the sad part is that it was better than 17
>>
>>87175118
>6.3, 9.2, 5.2, 6.9, 7.2
I don't understand how people can use a system with 100 datapoints, 10 or 20 is enough retard
>>
>>87172888
good to see more people liking TJC
>>87178877
why .5 for tmr
>>
>>87172062
not based
>>87172478
not based
>>87172511
not based
>>87172533
not based
>>87172582
based
>>87172650
based
>>87172788
based
>>87172888
not based
>>87172898
???
>>87172976
not based
>>87173024
NOT based
>>87173917
based
>>87174217
more than five ratings, NOT BASED!
>>87174260
based
>>87175118
BASED!
>>87176143
not based
>>87176716
based
>>87176801
not based
>>87176883
based
>>87177086
based
>>87177984
not based
>>87178877
not based
>>87178973
based
>>87180773
based
>>87180819
based!
>>87180897
extremely based
>>87180934
not based
>>87181400
(not) based
>>
File: not lame.jpg (95 KB, 1440x1080)
95 KB
95 KB JPG
>>87181962
>based
thanks you too
>>
File: rym.png (58 KB, 935x315)
58 KB
58 KB PNG
>>
>>87180974
>I dont understand that people consume and analyze art differently than me
>retard
this is a great post
>>
>>87183400
Justify giving ratings to 0.1 precision then
>>
>>87183598
Not the guy you responded to but here goes.

For the majority of my ratings, I use a scale in increments of 0.25, on a scale that goes to 10. 95% of my ratings follow this pattern.

However, I will use ratings on a 0.1 scale increment in specific situations. Most recently this occurred with an album that I relistened to, rated each track as I went along, and found at the end that the average track rating left me with an overall of about 6.42.
I couldn’t quite legitimize rounding the album score up to 6.5 as I didn’t think it was quite as good as other albums I had rated such, but I also found it slightly better than all my 6.25 albums.

So I rounded down from 6.42 to 6.4, and left the score as such.
>>
>>87183598
what do you mean justify it? Do you know that ratings are just reflections of what people think of music? The justification for giving something a 7.3 is the fact that I feel that it is a 7.3. I'm either getting trolled or you are a 15 year old. Maybe both. Either way fuck off lol
>>
>>87183711
I think he rather doesnt believe youre able to tell the difference between a 7.2 and 7.3, which is understandable since few people are able to, and honestly I dont believe youre able to either (because internet) but im not rarted enough to call you out on it
>>
Bump
>>
File: IMG_20190416_110807.jpg (193 KB, 1679x951)
193 KB
193 KB JPG
just created an account in this website so rated 5 records that are very fresh in my head
>>
File: listens.png (95 KB, 1313x390)
95 KB
95 KB PNG
>>87172062
>>
File: garbage.png (77 KB, 927x334)
77 KB
77 KB PNG
mostly overrated garbage
>>
File: 22222222.png (63 KB, 723x325)
63 KB
63 KB PNG
>>
>>87185977
Christ, i'd talk about being a harsh reviewer. What a faggot. I'd love to see what you consider a 5 star album
>>
File: rym2.png (62 KB, 748x378)
62 KB
62 KB PNG
>>87172062
>>
>>87185977
ABSOLUTELY BASED
fuck exuma its trash
>>87185880
bro is this your first day on planet earth?
>>
forgpt to post pic
>>
File: file.png (252 KB, 983x1016)
252 KB
252 KB PNG
>>87172650
hell yea, I really like hilo. reminds me a lot of lemon demon
>>87172888
disgusting gfoty rating, highly dissagree. what didnt you like about it? also good lift to experience rating
>>87172898
gold is good dammit! have you listened to their other record? way better then this one imo
>>87175118
gnnn i cant wait to listen to that syntheosis record, really excited for it!
btw, was it you that told me to look at dog whistle from another angle? because it really grew on me and I gotta thank the person who told me to give it another chance
>>87180897
wtf is that finished record
>>87181400
good caretaker rating. cant stand that pretentious fuck
>>87178031
then whats your favorite genre? let me give you some deep cuts :)
>>
File: rym5.png (92 KB, 1305x431)
92 KB
92 KB PNG
>>
File: amen.jpg (212 KB, 910x1070)
212 KB
212 KB JPG
>>87181962
Didn't think you browsed here, tbqh.
>>87183034
Eclectic as FVCK
https://www.discogs.com/Gaan-Untitled/master/387652
>>87180819
Really should dive deeper into shakir or
house music in general...
>>
>>87188540
Agree on no geography
Ventura is amazing though so I can’t agree there
>>87187812
Agree with yrself is steam
>>87185880
Graduation is great
Pinkerton is Barely overrated
DSOTM is slightly underrated
Agree with TMS
>>87183034
Agree on suicide s/t
>>87181962
Slightly underrated for RHS
>>87180897
Underrated for RHS
I don’t care for ? Either
>>87180773
Thank u next is too high
>>87178877
Ventura is great though I have it even higher
TMR is a hard album to rate but I would easily give it more than that
>>87178973
Put paak and TMB up half a star each and I agree
>>87177984
Agree on playboi
>>87176801
Titanic rising is overhyped imo
>>87176883
Agree with murmur
>>87176716
Titanic rising still overrated imo
>>87175118
Fifth dimension is kinda overrated imo
>>87174260
No geography needs half a star more
STH needs an extra star
>>87173569
Agree with TPAB
I don’t like daydream nation desu
Agree with funeral
>>87172976
Good score for yes
>>87172788
Ventura should be higher
Weyes blood lower
>>87172582
Agree with Y
>>87172478
Don’t like marquee moon that much but I respect the score
>>
>>87172650
Check out Heltah Skeltah's Nocturnal
>>
File: rym (4).jpg (80 KB, 728x374)
80 KB
80 KB JPG
I have no strong opinions one way or the other



Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.